News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A new theory about political polarization by Spooky23 on Monday June 29, 2020 @05:50PM (#23683623)
It adds alot of complexity with the questionable benefit of driving more extremism.
Re:A new theory about political polarization by TheOtherHobbes on Monday June 29, 2020 @06:17PM (#23683986)
The current system seems to be as extreme as it's possible to be without outright civil war. Generally the business of negotiating coalitions tends to temper extremism - see for example the new three-way Green and Centre-Right coalition in Ireland, which would have been unthinkable a couple of decades ago.

But considering the fact that political positions appear to correlate with brain structures, I honestly wonder if progressives and conservatives are no longer the same species.

Speciation happens when two mutations can no longer breed with each other. There's nothing in evolutionary theory that says the impediments can't be social and behavioural instead of anatomical.

Re:A new theory about political polarization by Spooky23 on Monday June 29, 2020 @06:46PM (#23684332)
That’s not a party problem, it’s an artifact of our mass experiment with various flavors of social media and unfiltered mass communication. The situation with Twitter giving maniacs a megaphone, Facebook radicalizing anyone and YouTube offering a twisty tunnel of crazy to drive engagement isn’t sustainable.

The counter response will be a lockdown and that will address most of the issue. Unfortunately there is plenty of suffering and discord to be had before that happens.

Re:A new theory about political polarization by jacobr1 on Monday June 29, 2020 @06:39PM (#23684248)
> But considering the fact that political positions appear to correlate with brain structures

The do now, but didn't historically. So (presuming the correlation is true) are any of the historical factors relevant to changing things today?

It seems like historically there were more dimensions to consider such as class, regional interests, religion and then within those combination of factors you could have a more-liberal or conservative view.

> There's nothing in evolutionary theory that says the impediments can't be social and behavioural instead of anatomical.

There is some data to support this. Charles Murray's Coming Apart cited a big trend of separation amongst the urban/liberal/educated and rural/conservative/religious. It really isn't enough to drive evolution, it certainly has an impact on culture and politics. There is no "reversion to the mean" if the distribution is binomial.