Re:A new theory about political polarization
by tunesmith on Monday June 29, 2020 @04:25PM
(#23682381)
Still not a tautology though; not-not wanting does not mean wanting.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Only because in your example wanting != wanting, which is an unfortunate consequence of the language not having a good word to differentiate between the desire to possess something and the desire not to be rid of it.
-(-A) == A, when A == A, is a tautology though.
Re:A new theory about political polarization
by tunesmith on Monday June 29, 2020 @05:25PM
(#23683300)
Still not true, for instance if A is "proven". If A is not not proven, it doesn't mean it is proven; it can still be a hypothesis. And yet, proven == proven.
Re:A new theory about political polarization
by jlokier on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @12:24AM
(#23686543)
> If A is not not proven, it doesn't mean it is proven; it can still be a hypothesis.
Are you sure?
It seems to me if A is not not-proven, it is surely proven.
If A is still just a hypothesis, then it is not-proven, and isn't not not proven.
Re:A new theory about political polarization
by jlokier on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @12:21AM
(#23686524)
> If A is not not proven, it doesn't mean it is proven; it can still be a hypothesis.
Are you sure?
It seems to me if A is not not-proven, it is surely proven.
If A is still just a hypothesis, then it is not-proven.