News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Challenges and opportunities for better nutrition science by watwut on Sunday June 28, 2020 @12:29PM (#23669902)
Calorie counting alone will have you simply not have enough of nutritients you need in the long term. You will feel bad and sick and passive, you wont be able to focus, you will be sickly and depressive or angry, because you lack stuff your body needs. When you break it, it feels good. You start to be active and have better mood. Because your body is suddenly getting stuff it needs.

I am speaking from personal experience here.

> models who need to be a certain shape

The way models ate and lived in the past was not healthy tho. There were periods where the expectation basically amounted to "eating disorder".

> dancers [...] football players who need to be heavy so they don't get lifted off their feet by their competitors

There is way more that goes to sport food. They dont focus on calories. They focus specifically on protein at specific times and what not.

The thin vs large sport physics is absolutely not about calories only. It is a lot about what kind of sport you do, whether endurance or cardio or strength.

Re:Challenges and opportunities for better nutrition science by snowwrestler on Sunday June 28, 2020 @12:45PM (#23670043)
What I said:

> Calorie counting functions properly for controlling weight.

That's an intentionally limited statement of what it works for. I agree with you on nutrients.

> There is way more that goes to sport food. They dont focus on calories. They focus specifically on protein at specific times and what not.

When they have specific weight targets, they do count calories. I posted some examples lower in this thread.

Re:Challenges and opportunities for better nutrition science by watwut on Sunday June 28, 2020 @01:16PM (#23670324)
> Calorie counting functions properly for controlling weight.

This is however completely useless goal if you dont add those other requirements like "while staying reasonably healthy and functional".

> When they have specific weight targets, they do count calories. I posted some examples lower in this thread.

The people who are trying to gain weight for sport really don't focus on calories. They focus on total amount of protein. They dont want sugar nearly as much and would not replace one with another.