Both things are a shame because I liked his blog a lot (along with Chen's)
It seems, according to Michael Kaplan, that he was fired from Microsoft for taking a photo with a personal camera of a framed plaque of a patent certificate with his name on it where the patent number was too visible. That is some horrid garbage.
Having gone through the corporate patent game myself it’s not something I would ever recommend.
Does anyone know why taking a photo of a patent (with the patent number visible) would be a fireable offence? I thought patents were public?
Although, on re-reading his statement, the firing wasn't the taking a picture of a patent, but including some ("infamous") art in another blog post.
That blog article is available at https://web.archive.org/web/20170623173912/http://archives.m...
He blogged about it ten years later at http://archives.miloush.net/michkap/archive/2015/09/04/87706...
First to note you can easily find all patents with Microsoft as applicant and Michael Kaplan as inventor, eg via Espacenet.
So, it's possible the "frame" is the issue.
Suppose a patent was issued without Kaplan listed as inventor, or with others listed who did not have a role. Then a frame saying "thanks to $people for their [sole] effort on this project" could become part of a lawsuit (not necessarily in USA) for the right to be named as inventor; in UK for example a significant contribution can require that an employee is reasonably compensated. That can be worth $USD millions (eg recent case 'Shanks v Unilever and others'). Based on this even just the wall the frame is on saying "significant contributions" or something might make a court case work that otherwise wouldn't.
I very much doubt that's the reason, but it gives me pause that a missing detail might explain the whole thing. Kaplan wouldn't even need to be aware of it.
It could also be something as simple as the company wanting an excuse to fire him, and "photos of any materials associated with patents is a firable offence" being in his contract.
Anybody able to explain why this would be an offense? I mean, patent numbers are visible to everyone, since a patent has to be listed, no?
I did not know him and he did not know me, but when I worked at Microsoft I would see him around campus. Small story, I remember one day in the building 10 cafeteria he asked me to hand him a bag of jalapeño potato chips he could not reach in his IBOT thing. Seemed like a nice guy. I later read in his final blog posts that he had a fairly eccentric personal life.
I am late to say it, but RIP.
http://archives.miloush.net/michkap/archive/2010/03/21/99827...
Also, people come and go in management and HR. Getting one kind of treatment at point A doesn't necessarily mean you get it at point B.