You may ask, isn't it a waste of time going through this rigamole? Of course, it is a waste of time for the super brilliant people; however, majority of them are like average you and me.
Even ignoring arts and humanities PhDs which are obvious cases, in fields like biology a newly minted average PhD has roughly zero people competing for them. They’ll be lucky to find a job even close to their field. You have biology PhDs working as Clinical Research Associates, for heaven’s sake.
You can be a high-school teacher in your subject for example.- I don't think we have a shortage of teachers! Or you can work in industry.
Not everyone does a PhD in order to get onto a tenure track at a college, which is what I think you meant.
There is a massive, massive oversupply of PhDs. We can argue about the magnitude of the oversupply, but the reasonable range of discussion is between “huge” and “gigantic”.
There clearly isn't - since there's such huge competition to hire them. If there was a massive oversupply they'd be unemployed.
Maybe top-flight CS PhDs from Stanford, I’d believe that. But your average biology or chemistry PhD? Every single one of them that I know struggled mightily in the job market.
In what sense do we have too many PhDs? The market for PhDs is pretty competitive.