The point of the Gibbs paradox is that exchanging two different shoes of the same color is not a new microstate, if all black shoes are considered identical. When they should be considered identical and when they shouldn't be is a bit more complicated, and the Jaynes paper goes into that.
The point of the Gibbs paradox is that exchanging two different shoes of the same color is not a new microstate, if all black shoes are considered identical. When they should be considered identical and when they shouldn't be is a bit more complicated, and the Jaynes paper goes into that.