News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What vertical farming and ag startups don't understand ab... by carapace on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @03:24PM (#23632674)
I've been thinking about this in the context of applied ecology (Permaculture, et. al.) It's undeniable that modern mechanized mass agriculture is incredibly efficient and already highly automated. It's kind of fantastic. (And very challenging to compete against.)

The two main downsides (IMO) are related: fragility and ecological ignorance.

The article touches on this: "soil is a natural resource that will become endangered if we do not mitigate the severe erosion problems that stem from single species field that are barren (re: nothing actively growing) for 30-40% of the calendar year (in North America)."

(Imagine installing millions of acres of solar panels and just switching them off for 1/3 of the year.)

Broadly speaking, if our agriculture destroys topsoil rather than creating it we're gonna have a bad time.

An interesting challenge would be to automate food forests. For concreteness, check out what these folks are doing: https://www.youtube.com/user/plantabundance

This is one family working on their home plot in a suburb who have converted it into a really cool food forest with chickens and lots and lots of different crops.

Imagine replicating this across millions of acres, without involving hundreds of thousands of people (which wouldn't be a bad thing, but it couldn't compete with mechanized agriculture.) What kind of automation could help with that?

Re:What vertical farming and ag startups don't understand ab... by mespe on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @07:58PM (#23635272)
Fallow fields are essential to maintaining soil health, a successful practice going back 10k years. Additionally, some of the "barren" fields are actually being used to alternate crop - it is a technique to grow crops with limited natural water. Modern best-practices avoid a lot of erosion by using no-till or low-till systems.
Re:What vertical farming and ag startups don't understand ab... by carapace on Thursday June 25, 2020 @12:09PM (#23642274)
I read up and watched some videos in re: "syntropic agriculture" last night. Ernst Götsch's farm produces crops all year w/o any inputs and with continuous improvement of the soil quality.