Dedicated eReaders
But, WHAT IN THE WORLD ARE THESE COMPANIES DOING?.. spending the resources on developing electronics dedicated to reading books. Same applies to Amazon with the Kindle. Okay, I suppose one could argue (at least in B&N' case) that they are appealing to their specific audience with modern tech. Nevertheless, why would a consumer spend $250+ on a device just to read books? B&N.com, if they really care about their costumers, should put an ad up that says: “We do not recommend spending $250 on a dedicated eReader.”
Sure Apple (i.e. iPad/iPad2) offers an eReader... but it's just one of 65,000+ apps.
Let’s organize a group and barge into B&N’s next board meeting, explain in plain English where our planet is heading with tech, and help them diversify/liquidate+re-invest in a better model.
Sorry (but not really); I felt the need to vent.
- Cheaper ($149 or $249 compared to $499)
- Easier to read (eInk is a lot easier on the eye when reading for long periods than a backlit display)
- Not confusing (Granted, an iPad is pretty easy to figure out, but for an average consumer a device that does one thing is generally easier to grasp)
- Better battery life (Nook claims 10 days, iPad claims 10 hours)
The two technologies may converge in the future, but for now, the dedicated eBook Reader still has its place.
weight too, i still cant get over how heavy an iPad feels, after using a 200 gram ereader
The point being, it's pretty close to stabilizing, at which point Amazon can just keep dropping the price as components get cheaper. Then Amazon can sell more and more of them, and sell more and more Amazon ebooks. If the Kindle's cost falls enough, Amazon can give them away.
By contrast, general-purpose tablets are going to be under constant pressure to keep upgrading the components, with faster CPUs, more RAM, better color screens, new wireless tech, better GPUs, more storage, so that users can use the latest software and run the latest apps. That'll help keep the prices relatively high.
If you think of dedicated eReaders, or at least the Kindle, as being like a simple 4-function calculator, it might be clearer. Calculators like that used to be expensive way back when. Now they're cheap enough to give away free with magazine subscriptions. There's little point in upgrading the hardware, so they just get cheaper and cheaper.
At least in the Kindle's case: selling a hell of a lot of them, and a hell of a lot of books.
Ever since I got a Kindle, I don't really use my iPad anymore.
My Kindle cost ($139) and weighed a fraction of what my iPad did. I can securely carry my kindle in the pocket of my cargo pants or my jacket without weighing me down.
It's easy on my eyes. A LOT easier. And I can read it outside with sunglasses on.
I read & download books and PDFs like mad.
I use klip.me (http://klip.me) & Instapaper (http://instapaper.com) to shoot every interesting web article to my Kindle automatically.
I shoot work-related documents to the Kindle via Whispernet for free.
I keep all my tech books on it. I find the resolution completely fine for tech books, btw. I was worried about this after reading Kindle DX reviews. I am working through Big Nerd Ranch's latest iOS programming book, which is full of illustrations.
I keep cheatsheets galore on it (packetlife, wireshark, vim, ipv6, etc)
And what I've come to find out, is that I largely use my iPad to read stuff. I don't play games. I watch movies, but I can just use my MBP for that.
In most cases, I find the Kindle handles things better, for a fraction of the cost. I can browse Google Reader on my iPhone, or my MBP. I've already got two expensive devices to handle the Kindle/iPad gap. But your YMMV.
Please don't misunderstand me on this, I actually really like ereaders. I think if you are a person that used to go on vacation with four heavy books in your luggage then they are great. I also really like a lot of the tech involved. The kindle's battery life is simply amazing.
The point is that I feel like the barrier to buying a book has been dramatically reduced. IMHO, this is why the bookstores are supporting and promoting them. With a physical book, you have to order it from the site or go to the store. You also have a physical book which can feel like 700 pages of procrastination staring you back in the face everyday that you don't read. Sure the bookworms out there really want you to like books and to actually read more, but bookstores are a business, and their business is _selling_ books.
i'd love a transflective ipad with image-persistence on powerdown. notionink seems to offer this i think?
I guess I'm just looking at this from an investment standpoint. If iPad offers 50%=.5 of the eReader quality against Kindle, Nook, etc. then the iPad (for eReading) cost equates to (~$5001/65,000)(.5) = .038 cents.
... There is room to argue that nobody is going to download 65,000 apps (and memory won't even allow for it). But still, the cost/benefit is substantially in favor of an all-inclusive tablet.
*That is, if you like to use gadgets for multiple apps.
Maybe BN should introduce a Color Nook Pad, with slightly better hardware, and enter into the Android tablet market. They already have a large retail network. There is a big opening for tablets priced under $500.
Venting about eReaders, the ones I've tried out are all so slow and clunky. Unless you don't need a tablet, like ever, you're better off spending the $250 on eBooks to read on your computer or tablet.