News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rising Wealth Inequality: Should We Care? by anamax on Thursday March 24, 2011 @12:15AM (#2362827)
> This attitude strikes me as naive. Much of "what you have" is only valuable relative to what others have.

Not at all. The pleasure that I get from a trip to Mexico is not affected by whether someone else can go Fiji. The benefit that I get from owning a house in San Jose has nothing to do with the cost of Bill Gates' mansion. The fun that I have driving my car isn't affected by the amount of money that Larry Ellison spends on boats.

> This is especially true of cash

Actually, it's the least true of cash.

> but also true of illiquid goods that you value at least partly for their social function or status.

There's your problem - you're assuming that I care about what other people have after I explicitly said that I don't.

As Feynman said, why do you care what other people think?

Or rather, if you do, isn't that your problem? Why should that problem justify doing anything to other people?

> Would driving a Porsche (say) be exactly as valuable to you whether or not everyone else had one?

Absolutely, Except that I want a Jaguar, not a Porsche.

There are no comments on this comment yet.