News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pseudonymity as a Trivial Concession to Genius by tptacek on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @08:20PM (#23622255)
In my view, for SSC to be permanently deleted would be an intellectual loss on the scale of, let’s say, John Stuart Mill or Mark Twain burning their collected works. That might sound like hyperbole, but

You can stop right there.

I don't want to get into a prolonged litigation of the Slate Star Codex oeuvre. You can like it or loathe it. But at some point people on these threads need to speak up and say that this blogger is not in fact the second coming of John Stuart Mill --- or at least, that's not the universally held opinion of people in tech. I know, he goes on to hedge his claim the same way. But let's retain candor. You can employ hyperbole if you feel it helps a valid argument, but it remains hyperbole.

Re:Pseudonymity as a Trivial Concession to Genius by Barrin92 on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @09:11PM (#23622731)
I know this will go down like a lead balloon on HN but I've never seen anything as cringeworthy and pseudo-intellectual as this entire rationalist subculture, where weird obsessions with Bayesianism or other highly technical lingo is applied to all sorts of topics in ways that just make anyone else roll their eyes.

I think this also ties into this latest drama because apparently Scott seems himself like some medieval scholar being persecuted by the authorities if his name ever comes up, which is dramatic given that his pseudonym is his actual first and middle name which together with "psychiatrist ann arbor" gives you his actual name on a google search and a picture. Any of his patients who has ever googled his name knows who he is.

Re:Pseudonymity as a Trivial Concession to Genius by norswap on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @08:18AM (#23627002)
Also, it should go down. If you're going to call something vile, you should at least provide some argument to that effect.

Second, and not that it matters, but searching Scott's real name does not link him as the author of SSC, which is what Scott cares about.

Rationalists have written a lot about: - making better arguments, and discursive standards - holding truer beliefs no matter if it goes against your current beliefs or makes you appear "cringeworthy"or "pseudo-intellectual"

Maybe you really ought to check them out?

Re:Pseudonymity as a Trivial Concession to Genius by Barrin92 on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @01:48PM (#23631334)
>but searching Scott's real name does not link him as the author of SSC, which is what Scott cares about.

tried it in an anonymous browsing session. Googling just his real name returns a link to the SSC twitter as the very first result, a rational wiki entry to scott alexander, and plenty of pictures at SSC meetups, so I have to assume any of his patients who ever Googled his name (which I guess is most people) probably know who he is

Re:Pseudonymity as a Trivial Concession to Genius by norswap on Thursday June 25, 2020 @11:01AM (#23641524)
Good point, but only if you include the middle name (Alexander), and except for one of these links that is a bona fide doxing, most are matches for "Scott Alexander".
Re:Pseudonymity as a Trivial Concession to Genius by danharaj on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @09:53AM (#23627870)
Unfortunately the rationalist community basically engages in sophistry centered around a naive and outdated positivism with Bayes' rule slapped on top.
Re:Pseudonymity as a Trivial Concession to Genius by papeda on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @08:30PM (#23622375)
In slight fairness to Aaronson, he doesn't present this as a "universally held opinion of people in tech", as the rest of that excerpt goes to say:

> . . . but not (I don’t think) to the tens of thousands who read Scott’s essays and fiction, particularly during their 2013-2016 heyday, and who went from casual enjoyment to growing admiration to the gradual recognition that they were experiencing, “live,” the works that future generations of teachers will assign their students when they cover the early twenty-first century.

So he's pretty much saying Slate Star Codex has fans who will miss it a lot.

(I do agree with you that the comparison is pretty nuts, even as someone who thinks Slate Star Codex has a lot of good stuff.)

Re:Pseudonymity as a Trivial Concession to Genius by pdonis on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @08:34PM (#23622403)
> he's pretty much saying Slate Star Codex has fans who will miss it a lot

No, he's not, he's saying, explicitly, in what you quoted, that "future generations of teachers will assign their students" Slate Star Codex as reading material. That's waaaay beyond "fans who will miss it a lot".

Re:Pseudonymity as a Trivial Concession to Genius by tptacek on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @08:36PM (#23622430)
Can I say that the plain meaning of these words --- "generations" connoting teachers en masse, the way generations of teachers have for decades assigned the "I Have A Dream Speech" --- is also pretty obviously hyperbolic.

Maybe you believe the blog was headed in some genius direction, and lament a lost future. But you can't reasonably suggest that the SSC that exists today is going to be taught in schools.

Or, again, if you do, you can't claim to hold the mainstream opinion on the matter. I believe all sorts of weird shit nobody else believes; I'm not casting stones.

Re:Pseudonymity as a Trivial Concession to Genius by pdonis on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @08:38PM (#23622450)
> you can't reasonably suggest that the SSC that exists today is going to be taught in schools.

I'm not. But I'm not so sure Scott Aaronson wasn't. Call it hyperbole if you like, since technically Aaronson put those words in the hypothetical mouth of a hypothetical SSC fan, but my reading is closer to "Freudian slip".

Re:Pseudonymity as a Trivial Concession to Genius by tptacek on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @08:49PM (#23622548)
Rhetorical "you"! Sorry about that.
Re:Pseudonymity as a Trivial Concession to Genius by norswap on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @08:12AM (#23626956)
Does Scott Aaronson speak for the tech community now?

I'll take Scott Alexander over Mark Twain any day, and this is my my belief and not hyperbole, thank you very much.

So what? People disagree over the internet, big whoop.

What's your comment supposed to achieve exactly? Chastize us for our profanity? Recast our sincere appreciation as mere hyperbole? Please.

Re:Pseudonymity as a Trivial Concession to Genius by tptacek on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @10:08AM (#23628021)
So what? If I'm honest, I'd take Dominic Armato, the guy who wrote the Top Chef Power Rankings, over James Joyce. But, for obvious reasons, I wouldn't write a public appeal suggesting that Armato is more important than Joyce.
Re:Pseudonymity as a Trivial Concession to Genius by norswap on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @07:45PM (#23635170)
But, why not? If you believe Dominic Armato is that good, why not try to convince other people he's worth looking into?

(I agree that in any case, making rankings of writers isn't very useful.)

Aaronson wasn't trying to make an appeal that Scott Alexander should be elevated to the level of Mark Twain. It was just his honest opinion (or, maybe, hyperbole - I'm not in Scott Aaronson's brain), stated while discussing why doxxing Scott Alenxander is bad.

If that - speaking your mind on the level you believe someone to be at - is bad, then it certainly isn't obvious to me.

Re:Pseudonymity as a Trivial Concession to Genius by tptacek on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @08:14PM (#23635364)
Because I have enough perspective to know that my appreciation for a blogger who did a good job writing power rankings for a reality show does not indicate they achieved something on the same level as James Joyce.
Re:Pseudonymity as a Trivial Concession to Genius by norswap on Thursday June 25, 2020 @11:06AM (#23641575)
Fine, but then it's a question of nuance - you could say James Joyce's command of the English language is better for instance (or whatever, this is just an example).

Saying that one believes it would be as bad to lose Scott's writing as Twain's is not saying he believes Scott should be thaught in English classes. It's just in essence saying "I value this a whole damn lot".