Re:133 US cities now have their own broadband networks
by jarpadat on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @06:21PM
(#2361720)
Look, I am a libertarian too and I'm 100% with you that government coercion is bad. But running fiber totally depends on a lot of unrelated people agreeing to have their land dug up, and in any practical circumstance that requires coercion.
The government is already involved, whether your bill says "AT&T" or "Chattanooga Municipal". The only question is whether data lines remain under the collective control of the people whose land they actually run under or whether that control is ceded by that government to a private corporation. The difference is who wags the government's tail, not whether that force is used.
Re:133 US cities now have their own broadband networks
by lutorm on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @06:59PM
(#2361873)
I'm viewing government as a collection of citizens joining together to run society. You Americans (I assume you are) have an extremely paranoid and depressing view of society. Maybe you should try living in a country where the democratic process works better than the dysfunctional U.S. system for a couple of years.
In particular, as a user of cable, a private cable company cannot force you to accept and pay for its service. A government-operated cable service could.
From the perspective of a private cable company, government competition is unfair. The government does not have to use non-coercive means. It can force people to pay for its service even if they don't want to.
In the US, the best illustration of the danger of government enterprises is the public school system. Residents of an area are forced to support the local public schools, even if they send their children to private schools. The long-term loss of human potential of this system is monstrous. The economic waste is pretty bad too.
The best way to avoid disasters like the US public school system is to insist that transactions be voluntary. If you want to operate a cable company, fine, do it, but don't expect to be able to use coerced money to fund it or coercion to operate it.