Re:What ‘less lethal’ weapons do
by throw1234651234 on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @12:41PM
(#23616393)
The problem you are trying to underline is that these are meant to be an alternative when force is absolutely necessary, whereas a lot of users pretend they are "safe" options to be used in any situation without harm.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Yeah. Maybe the root cause here is how to interpret 'absolutely necessary'. It's clear, however, that the police interpretation is overly broad, and they cannot be trusted to deploy these in the emergencies that might warrant them.
It can be made easy: these are alternatives to use of a firearm. They should only be allowed where deadly force is legally justified, though policies could call for using them before firearms when possible, e.g. to incapacitate a person who is brandishing a weapon, but not actively hurting people with it.
Re:What ‘less lethal’ weapons do
by MaxBarraclough on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @01:15PM
(#23617005)
> They should only be allowed where deadly force is legally justified, though policies could call for using them before firearms when possible, e.g. to incapacitate a person who is brandishing
These two proposed policies are contradictory.
They're not, because legal justification and department policy are different. If, for example, someone is threatening people with a knife and is close enough to use it, the law usually allows a police officer to shoot that person without taking any other actions.
Department policy can require the use of specific tactics to maximize opportunities to resolve situations with minimal force. An example policy would be to attempt to separate the subject from bystanders, delay until backup arrives, negotiate verbally, then use less lethal weapons, only resorting to firearms if someone is about to be stabbed.
Re:What ‘less lethal’ weapons do
by MaxBarraclough on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @01:53PM
(#23617616)
I see what you're saying now, I'd misread you.
Re:What ‘less lethal’ weapons do
by closeparen on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @12:48PM
(#23616506)
“When force is absolutely necessary” generally means a life-and-death situation, where police are going to use deadly force anyway.
The potential use of force is absolutely necessary for the enforcement of any law, otherwise it's just a polite suggestion that can and often will ultimately be ignored by antisocial individuals.
Now, personally, I would love to live in a society populated solely by considerate, thoughtful, and polite people who always follow polite suggestions and don't need to be forcefully coerced. However we don't live in that society and the claim that we don't because of law enforcement using force is very much an example of wet streets causing rain.