Re:Detroit is Dying… Quickly
by dog_dog on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @03:50PM
(#2361087)
he's implying that black people are killing detroit. Look at the population of whites to blacks from 1820 to 2000.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Detroit is Dying… Quickly
by archangel_one on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @05:09PM
(#2361476)
No he's not. Correlation is not causation.
ie. just because Detroit is going through economic changes and the proportion of black people in Detroit has increased across the same period, that does not necessarily mean those black people are responsible for said economic changes.
I wasn't implying anything. I was linking to data that I found interesting. Black populations have been increasing (though have recently plateaued). It's the whites that have been decreasing since ~1950.
That was my assumption, but also why I asked for clarification. I try not to take the worst possible interpretation as truth. But if that's the case, I would just point out Atlanta. It's half-black and doing fine. So it'd be silly to claim.
"Blackness" seems like a poor metric for economic vibrancy.
When I moved from Europe to America, my neighborhood went black. White flight seemed to kill all the businesses around my neighborhood. The "Blackness" of an area can't be ignored but it doesn't account for Detroit's problems.
Re:Detroit is Dying… Quickly
by baguasquirrel on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @04:31PM
(#2361296)
America has "black" problems that Europe may not have.
look Europe has a problem in accepting non western cultures, lets not enter into that useless debate here on HN..
Re:Detroit is Dying… Quickly
by baguasquirrel on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @10:19PM
(#2362524)
Europe does. But I realize the way that I put it was not constructive.
There is no debate. In Europe, they have a problem of communication between classes. In America, we have a problem of communication between communities. One society is not better than the other. That is same tired old "debate" that we should avoid here.
Re:Detroit is Dying… Quickly
by rsheridan6 on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @05:25PM
(#2361537)
When I looked at the link I thought he was trying to show that Detroit's been in decline for a long time. I guess it's like a Rorschach ink blot.