News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sugary drink tax models show health gains, cost reduction... by nightski on Monday June 22, 2020 @09:29AM (#23599912)
Sugar is not made artificially cheap. It's actually more expensive in the U.S. due to government control over the market (production, imports, and exports). If the government subsidies/control was not there, the U.S. sugar market would disappear as it cannot compete with the global market. You'd see a massive reduction in sugar prices and a lot of U.S. farms go under.

In fact, big customers of the sugar companies lobby for this to happen all the time (think Hershey). They'd love the U.S. sugar industry to collapse. It's a constant battle.

Re:Sugary drink tax models show health gains, cost reduction... by cycrutchfield on Monday June 22, 2020 @10:32AM (#23600595)
>You'd see a massive reduction in sugar prices and a lot of U.S. farms go under.

An honest question, why is this a big issue? If US farms are not competitive producing sugar, why are we incentivizing them to do so?

Re:Sugary drink tax models show health gains, cost reduction... by tikhonj on Monday June 22, 2020 @11:53AM (#23601591)
A couple of ideas:

1. There are strategic reasons for a country to maintain a strong agricultural sector in case of international instability, war... etc. In today's economy we can't be 100% independent, but we still need some level of independence we wouldn't get without government intervention.

2. Other countries are undercutting our prices for reasons we find unethical: extremely low wages, inhuman working conditions, literal slavery... etc. We can't control other countries directly on these fronts, but we can at least ensure that we do not contribute to those practices ourselves.

3. Other countries are driving prices down through government subsidies in a bid to gain control of the market, and our tariffs compensate for that.

I have no clue whether these reasons apply to sugar specifically, or whether the US policy on these questions is proportional and effective. But at least it illustrates that there are reasons why a policy like that makes sense for the country as a whole (and not just for sugar producers).

Re:Sugary drink tax models show health gains, cost reduction... by kemitche on Monday June 22, 2020 @10:49AM (#23600821)
I don't know if this is the actual reason, but I can see value in a country protecting it's food supply to ensure that long-term, they stay self sufficient. Subsidies that keep production local would be a means to that end.
Re:Sugary drink tax models show health gains, cost reduction... by cycrutchfield on Monday June 22, 2020 @11:53AM (#23601596)
We don’t care about being self-sufficient in avocado production, so why do we care about corn so much? I feel like the self-sufficiency is a post-hoc rationalization and the real reason has more to do with politics and lobbying.