If you do a quick head count of people who know about this effect in 12 months it may well turn out most of them learned it from YouTube.
Here's another example from a while back:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21911225 - "How an Alzheimer’s ‘cabal’ thwarted progress toward a cure"
When you've got enough incentive, it's hard to resist the urge to use your power to simply decide what is and is not allowed to be true.
While this does happen, science at least allows the possibility of enough evidence to force people into accepting the new model. Without science, many more things are considered untouchable dogma and there is no method to challenge that.
Scientists are still human and make dumb ego driven mistakes, science still provides the best theory out there.
https://grants.nih.gov/grants/guide/pa-files/PAR-19-369.html
Isn’t his claim that the lab mice adopted to some change in telomeres that significantly distorted the results of tests? I guess famous intellectuals with PhD aren’t credible sources but Eric Weinstein said that for over a decade they tried to get publicity for the story but ran into resistance.
I think it is in part a symptom of the cost of research causing labs to be centered moreso around a methodology than a question. Having some labs like this isn't a problem, but when an entire field starts to trend this way, and almost everything that gets funding chooses a particular side of a tradeoff (that isn't super well quantified to begin with), then I think we could end up missing a lot.
There are tons of mouse labs, however some have specialized mice or mouse systems. There are also other labs that specialize in other animal systems. These systems are nontrivial to switch between for many reasons, which I think you acknowledge. It is useful for the field in general to have access to the results of a variety of research tools that every individual wouldn't necessarily have access to.
Poor GP.
Certainly if we hold these kind of ethics we've got no excuses if an advanced alien race wants to use us in their medical experiments.
I do agree that lab animals aren't a resource in themselves – they're just the currently "next best" model to test in before trying a drug out in humans. In fact, mice are actually quite expensive in terms of time and money – custom-genotype mice can cost hundreds of dollars each, and that's just the up-front purchase price. The overhead of maintaining a mouse line is also quite high, with a huge loss incurred for accidental death or euthanization before they've been used as a model. When many research facilities were first shut down due to COVID lockdown this year, I heard that many labs at my university had to euthanize all their mice as they wouldn't be able to care for them. This represents a loss of months of research time and possibly thousands to tens of thousands of research dollars.
Another thing to consider is that many drug candidates that make it to the animal testing stage don't succeed with safety and/or efficacy testing. According to the FDA, 92% of pre-clinical animal tests actually fail to predict drug effectiveness in humans. This highlights a pressing need for other fail-fast/fail-cheap methods that should precede animal testing, like cell culture methods that could be used as a pre-animal screen.
Thank you for the insightful comment, I'll cite the part that is relevant, since my (very serious) point was indeed that by this logic a more "advanced" being than us would have (by our own morals) the right to conduct medical experiments on us humans, because we are capable of feeling less pain.
If an advanced alien wants to use us in experiments, I doubt they'd care much about what we say on the matter. And for all we know, the aliens might come from a predator background and only consider vicious species as true equals.
It's not even comparable.
Every animal model is imperfect and the various tools to try to address them (e.g. greater genetic uniformity) have consequences as well.
If you pick the wrong model your research will fail. Even if it gets through the pure research phase, the FDA will want justification as for why your animal of choice is appropriate.
I had a program that required — ugh — guinea pigs. Those suckers ended up costing $1K when all was said and done (not the cost of acquiring them,but looking after them and running the program). Rats would have been cheaper and mice even more but theOr immune systems could reject the pathogen we were trying to treat; the GP was the least expensive animal it would attack. (There turned out to be other advantages too but that was that for research). And when it came time for the preclinical work for IND submission the agency wanted an EMEA more expensive animal because it was a better human model.
So it’s an engineering trade off, just like any other. One controlled for when possible. Sorry there’s no conspiracy.