News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Poll: Would you have dodged the Vietnam draft? by rms on Friday July 04, 2008 @01:58AM (#235983)
I'm curious to hear about the people that say no. Duty to your country? What makes me consider yes is the idea that war is an essentially human experience that may not exist for much longer, as we become more and more peaceful as society becomes more globalized. It is certainly not a good or romantic human experience.
Re:Poll: Would you have dodged the Vietnam draft? by pg on Friday July 04, 2008 @03:02PM (#236438)
war is an essentially human experience that may not exist for much longer

Not likely. It will just get more specialized. In a way, that's a return to its origins.

Re:Poll: Would you have dodged the Vietnam draft? by rms on Saturday July 05, 2008 @04:02AM (#236806)
50 years from now, units of unmanned robots will be able to do a lot of if not all of the winning fighting. We're going to have ground troops in exoskeletons. If Africa isn't stable yet, you could send a mechanized army into an airport before landing your invading force. See Simon Mann's failed run into Equatorial Guinea in 2004 (funded with only $20MM) for a way to impact Africa without an army of deadly robots.

Then, once the UN gains more power as Europe gains more power the world will get a lot more stable. What do we have left to fight for? Water can be distributed to everyone. Food can be distributed to everyone. If we just stopped all the fighting then we could afford to give everyone in the world food.

Do you think humanity is going to take more than a few hundred years to reach practical utopia? I'm very optimistic.

Re:Poll: Would you have dodged the Vietnam draft? by run4yourlives on Friday July 04, 2008 @12:57PM (#236331)
I was in the army after high school, albeit Canadian, and I don't think my choices would have changed if a war was on or not.
Re:Poll: Would you have dodged the Vietnam draft? by missenlinx on Friday July 04, 2008 @04:22AM (#236049)
Duty & self accomplishment.
Re:Poll: Would you have dodged the Vietnam draft? by petercooper on Friday July 04, 2008 @05:19AM (#236074)
I admire your sense of duty, but want to play devil's advocate for a second.

Should a slave continue to be enslaved out of a sense of duty to their master? Should a kid brought up in a religious family choose to remain in that faith merely out of a sense of duty?

It's curious how patriotism seems to instill a sense of duty in rational minds where even religion can find it tough to stick.

Re:Poll: Would you have dodged the Vietnam draft? by dazzawazza on Friday July 04, 2008 @07:06AM (#236132)
It's interesting that people are comparing the draft to slavery. Aren't wars fought to avoid being enslaved to the enemy.

I think modern wars are less clear cut but certainly for WWII Brits signed up to avoid slavery under the hun.

Re:Poll: Would you have dodged the Vietnam draft? by lesslucid on Friday July 04, 2008 @07:50AM (#236154)
If the people of a country are in serious danger of being enslaved by an enemy, chances are that many people will voluntarily join the army. An unpopular war of choice, on the other hand, may struggle greatly to raise as many voluntary troops as the government desires, and this is a circumstance where conscription is both most likely and most questionable. In WW2, British men not only "signed up" but were conscripted, but in this case I think you rightly allude to the fact that it was called for under the circumstances; there was a real danger of much greater evils than conscription being visited on the British people if the Nazis were to triumph. But since the thread started with a question about Vietnam, I think it's worth considering the smallness of the possibility of the Vietnamese achieving the enslavement of the American people or anything of the kind at the point in time when conscription was instituted for the prosecution of that war.
Re:Poll: Would you have dodged the Vietnam draft? by petercooper on Friday July 04, 2008 @10:04AM (#236217)
I was comparing patriotism to slavery, not the draft per-se. The concept of feeling duty for "one's country" seems very weird when you look at it with some detachment. In a very literal sense, my loyalties end at my family, let alone my town, county, country, planet, or whatever.

In any case, modern wars are far less clear. In terms of this specific post, no-one from Vietnam was getting ready to invade or enslave the US or Europe. It could be argued Vietnam was a necessary show of force to demonstrate that the West wouldn't allow the USSR to mark its mark all around the world, but it'd be a tenuous argument at best.