Unfortunately, most people don't reflect too deeply on the social consequences of their choice of employment.
Why is it any of your business how other people spend their time? There's no objective standard for morality.
>To make the roulette wheel run a little faster? I don't understand it.
Maybe try learning a bit about how markets work and the service they provide. Your criticism makes as much sense as somebody with no familiarity with the software industry complaining about encryption researchers wasting their time enabling child abuse.
The incentives are all messed up.
Hft could probably be "fixed" by some game rules. Like delaying any request by 10s+-some random delay. Then having an edge of some ms would just be noise.
Not everybody cares about those things, in fact I'd wager the majority of people I know in HFT would be bored to tears at the thought of working on emission control or children's education programs. What gives you the right to decide how other people should spend their time?
I have worked with ECU development and there are low hanging fruit to optimize for there if the effort, brainpower and money was put into it.
I just wish that more effort was put into "low margin" classical industrial design than artificial top of the pyramids' algorithms, like banks and ads.
Much of the development of high-performance network switches has been driven by HFT. I doubt Metamako would have been created if HFT wasn't around as a customer.
This is just whining of course I am not saving children at work either.
Where am I arguing this?
You could say the same thing about pushing ads. The fact is that if there’s something that generates money, smart people will gravitate towards it if they can increase margins in a competitive field no matter how useless it might seem.
(And to be extremely clear, I would say the same thing about pushing ads: just stop doing it. Walk away.)
It is not needless greed (as popularized by some movies and pop culture), it is an engine of the capitalist civilisation, which has so far produced far more results (even in less obvious terms like allowing for least poverty in the world than any other time in history, because the benefits of a well-functiouning society do evidently trickle down to the the little guy, even if the most of it is collected at the top) than any other.
There is indeed some meaningless speculation in it, just like how there is corruption in all of human systems, and just how in every ecosystem there are a number of parasites, but they are there because the underlying system (capitalism) is meaningful and produces value for society.
> feeding the unfed
They do feed the unfed. The capitalist system has been able to reduce world poverty by far far more than any other system in history. Look at the stats. And well-functioning capital, labor, idea and resource circulation markets are at the very heart of that system.
Sure. But I'd question whether high-frequency trading is a necessary component of that, as opposed to regular-frequency trading. Same as I'd question whether things like collateralized debt obligations and interest-free loans were good for the housing market.
"Capitalist civilization" has changed in a number of ways since Reagan and Thatcher, just in its legal framework, compared to the thirty years before and I don't think it's obvious at all that we are better off in the developed world than we were in the fifties and sixties when things were more regulated.
When I look at stats for things like wage disparities, and the amount of money poured into marketing (demand generation), and the amount of frivolous products that the capitalist economy produces because it must by its nature constantly expand production, I quite honestly don't see efficiency and I certainly don't see reason.
Have you considered its alternatives are not much better, if at all?
Right now there is no price discovery, all stocks are way overpriced.
While mainstreet is going in flames, wallstreet acts like everything is peachy and jumps on any rumor of a hint of a possibility that someone somewhere might someday have something that look like the possibility of a COVID vaccine (looking at you Gilead scam).
This won't end well (imo).
People have been saying that for decades. How many decades of successful operation are worth then having a couple of years of "won't end well"? Also why do we think that any other system would "end well" (whatever that specifically means)? It's not like there were never any economic crises or instability before FED and other organizations started manipulating the system that way.
I'm French and I'm convinced that in less than 2 years from now I won't pay with Euros anymore (maybe Francs or South Euros or whatever they will invent).
So at least for me it doesn't end well very soon. But even the FMI boss called for a big reset.