News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Companies Pitch Shortwave Radio to Shave Milliseconds Off... by sargun on Monday June 22, 2020 @01:38AM (#23597547)
I remain convinced that this is Starlink's short-term customer if their promises are true. They are doing transmission via optical as the crow flies. If they're doing O-O, or even low latency O-E-O, they can beat transatlantic fiber. For HFT houses, that's potentially a major edge.
Re:Companies Pitch Shortwave Radio to Shave Milliseconds Off... by modeless on Monday June 22, 2020 @02:57AM (#23597885)
Starlink latency would be worse than shortwave. The advantage would be bandwidth, but I doubt that high bandwidth is really helpful for this application, especially if you have to give up a tiny bit of latency for it. After all, you can already have all the bandwidth you want with only slightly higher latency.
Re:Companies Pitch Shortwave Radio to Shave Milliseconds Off... by alexpil on Monday June 22, 2020 @02:13PM (#23603614)
starlink latency could be faster than shortwave, once full gen2 constellation launches, and if starlink decides to care about this industry.

...disclosure: i'm the first one to build NY-Chi microwave, and Chi-Lon shortwave.

Re:Companies Pitch Shortwave Radio to Shave Milliseconds Off... by modeless on Monday June 22, 2020 @02:36PM (#23603923)
Cool! How do you figure? Doesn't shortwave take the great circle path, at lower altitude, making the path shorter?
Re:Companies Pitch Shortwave Radio to Shave Milliseconds Off... by alexpil on Monday June 22, 2020 @02:51PM (#23604168)
gen2 constellation is at 350km agl shortwave f-layer is at 200-400km agl depending on space weather

difference is not that big

Re:Companies Pitch Shortwave Radio to Shave Milliseconds Off... by modeless on Monday June 22, 2020 @03:17PM (#23604787)
Sure, but it seems to me like the Starlink path will still be longer in almost all cases unless you're incredibly lucky and the satellites line up exactly along the path for a few seconds. And Starlink could have additional delays related to routing and possibly TDMA. What kind of latency issues need to be considered with shortwave?
Re:Companies Pitch Shortwave Radio to Shave Milliseconds Off... by alexpil on Monday June 22, 2020 @08:03PM (#23608432)
a single orbital plane at 53' contains 7028 satellites (out of 40k total, but let's take one orbital plane)

basic math, "satellite density" or "average distance between satellites" if they were just at random position is ~200km (napkin math, might be off).

Re:Companies Pitch Shortwave Radio to Shave Milliseconds Off... by sargun on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @05:09AM (#23611529)
Some folks wrote a paper based on the proposed constellation: https://dl.acm.org/doi/10.1145/3286062.3286075

The paper actually talks about trading: > Already there are new private microwave relay links between New York and Chicago[11], London and Frankfurt[1], and London and Paris. These links have relatively low capacity compared to fiber, but are of high enough value to the finance industry to be worth building new low latency links

In their paper, they say NYC / LON RTT will be between 58 and 66 ms -- this isn't much better than fiber. On the other hand, London to Joburg -- starlink has an advantage.

Re:Companies Pitch Shortwave Radio to Shave Milliseconds Off... by alexpil on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @09:51AM (#23613903)
That paper is based on gen1 constellation, and predates gen2 (350km) announcement.
Re:Companies Pitch Shortwave Radio to Shave Milliseconds Off... by alexpil on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @10:51AM (#23614640)
more specifically, gen1 constellation was 1600 satellites per inclination at 1150km, gen2 is 7100 per inclination at 350km.
Re:Companies Pitch Shortwave Radio to Shave Milliseconds Off... by sargun on Monday June 22, 2020 @07:49PM (#23608324)
It's also bandwidth right? What's the throughput on shortwave? I believe that Starlink promises mbps+. I imagine there are applications you can implement on higher bandwidth are more interesting?

Was Pilosoft always an HFT thing?

Re:Companies Pitch Shortwave Radio to Shave Milliseconds Off... by alexpil on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @07:43PM (#23635156)
https://visionscarto.net/enquete-reseaux-hft and google translate for the backstory.

bandwidth is a few bits per message, a few messages per second.

yes you can do more with more bits and more messages, but you can do quite a lot with 2 bits!

Re:Companies Pitch Shortwave Radio to Shave Milliseconds Off... by hef19898 on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:14AM (#23598190)
If memory works well, they have dedicated glass fibre for bandwidth, at least between Chicago and NY. Took the closest possible distance.

Microwave is used for speed, in addition, to get binary signals from A to B. I heard that theory more than once about Starlink, it just doesn't make that much sense to me. Starlink could also be, of course, a clever way of getting

a) enough launches to make reusable rockets financially feasible

and/or

b) getting financing for SpaceX

Quite some other companies trying the same went under recently.

Re:Companies Pitch Shortwave Radio to Shave Milliseconds Off... by oh_sigh on Monday June 22, 2020 @03:35AM (#23598020)
What happens in the global market if a single person consistently has a timing advantage over every other participant(because the barrier to building a global satellite network is too high/costly for anyone else)? Could Elon come to own the entire market, or is there some limit to the powers of arbitrage?
Re:Companies Pitch Shortwave Radio to Shave Milliseconds Off... by logicchains on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:47AM (#23598345)
If a single player was capturing the entire arbitrage market, they'd be earning enough to justify other players building their own satellite network to capture a piece of the pie.
Re:Companies Pitch Shortwave Radio to Shave Milliseconds Off... by sargun on Monday June 22, 2020 @01:57PM (#23603426)
HFT firms make a lot of money...but space launch is even more costly. :(
Re:Companies Pitch Shortwave Radio to Shave Milliseconds Off... by alexpil on Monday June 22, 2020 @02:14PM (#23603622)
it'd be rather interestink.

but shortwave will be competitive with spacex, although at, of course, lower capacities.

for inter-market trading, sub-ms latency differences don't matter that much.

Re:Companies Pitch Shortwave Radio to Shave Milliseconds Off... by ncmncm on Monday June 22, 2020 @01:53AM (#23597599)
Starlink might get as much for denying access to specific other parties as for selling access in the first place.