Re:Why systemd is still divisive after all these years
by freedomben on Sunday June 21, 2020 @12:13PM
(#23592856)
Disclaimer: I word for Red Hat, but I'm here as a guy not as a RH employee
I was anti-systemd until I read the "Rethinking PID 1" blog post by Lennart Poettering[1]. I also became a huge advocate of "documenting decisions and history" because as a reader getting to see the thought process softened me up. It also reminded me that real life is sometimes a messy tradeoff of decisions.
That said I don't like the ever-growing scope creep either. Systemd is great to work with (not perfect, but nothing is) but I do worry about systemd encroaching on everything.
I would love to see Lennart or somebody else driving things write a new "Rethinking PID 1" that explains the thought process behind the different scope creeps. That would really help people like me make an honest judgment.
I was anti-systemd until I read the "Rethinking PID 1" blog post by Lennart Poettering[1]. I also became a huge advocate of "documenting decisions and history" because as a reader getting to see the thought process softened me up. It also reminded me that real life is sometimes a messy tradeoff of decisions.
That said I don't like the ever-growing scope creep either. Systemd is great to work with (not perfect, but nothing is) but I do worry about systemd encroaching on everything.
I would love to see Lennart or somebody else driving things write a new "Rethinking PID 1" that explains the thought process behind the different scope creeps. That would really help people like me make an honest judgment.
[1] http://0pointer.de/blog/projects/systemd.html