News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Art of the Possible by scarface74 on Saturday June 20, 2020 @01:01PM (#23584990)
I don’t get it. For context I am the first to criticize all of the wanna be lawyers on HN who don’t know what monopoly or anti trust is. But Apple’s stance is just dumb for a lot reasons. It’s not good for Apple, consumers or developers. There is a simple solution that would make everyone happy but the sleazy developers of pay to win games and I have no sympathy for them:

All “reader” apps and apps that have subscriptions for services must allow in app purchases. But through Apple Pay. Meaning they get charged standard credit card fees. Apple could even charge a slightly higher rate like 6% to cover the rewards program like other premium cards do.

This benefits:

Apple: They can bring all of the apps back into the fold like Netflix and Spotify and they can get Microsoft and Adobe in. It’s more money for Apple. On top of that, it gets both the EU and US government off their back.

Users: have a much better experience.

Developers: Get to keep more of their money.

It also excludes pay to win games. Between this and Apple Arcade, I am okay if all of those types of games die.

Also offer upgrade pricing capabilities for apps to make it easier for developers to make money without having to rely on subscriptions.

Re:The Art of the Possible by saagarjha on Saturday June 20, 2020 @03:17PM (#23586227)
This doesn't work at all in countries where Apple Pay is not a thing, or where Apple Pay doesn't have support from one or more major banks.
Re:The Art of the Possible by scarface74 on Saturday June 20, 2020 @05:03PM (#23587287)
Simple: you don’t have to offer Apple Pay in countries where it’s not available. That still covers the richest countries.
Re:The Art of the Possible by MarkMc on Saturday June 20, 2020 @07:42PM (#23588397)
> It’s more money for Apple

I'm not sure that would be true with a share of revenue set at 6%. Maybe 15% or 20%

Re:The Art of the Possible by scarface74 on Saturday June 20, 2020 @08:58PM (#23588784)
Considering that Apple gets no revenue from Netflix or Spotify from new subscribers any amount would be better.
Re:The Art of the Possible by jiofih on Saturday June 20, 2020 @01:17PM (#23585084)
That is in fact the solution Apple offers, all apps must offer purchases via Apple Pay. Except the fee is 30% and not 6%, and there lies the problem.
Re:The Art of the Possible by scarface74 on Saturday June 20, 2020 @01:29PM (#23585164)
That’s not Apple Pay. That’s in app purchasing. That’s a completely different payment flow.

In app purchasing: User pays Apple with the card on file with Apple. They take 30% and pay you in 30 days. You get a tax form at the end of the year.

Apple Pay: Multiple cards can be stored in your digital wallet on your device. Apple doesn’t store your credit cards on file. When you pay via Apple Pay, you choose the card,Apple takes a much smaller cut, the payment goes through the credit card network, through your merchant bank and you get paid within 2-3 days. Apple doesn’t even have a record of your transaction unless you’re using Apple’s credit card.

You are responsible for establishing the merchant account and taking care of card processing and refunds.

You are also responsible for making sure that users update their credit card information.

Re:The Art of the Possible by jiofih on Sunday June 21, 2020 @08:47AM (#23591722)
Sorry, mind fart. The point is Apple requires that subscriptions be available through them, and then take the 30% cut - you can’t, say, use Stripe to take new subscriptions inside the app. So what the parent suggested is already there, the problem is the size of the fee. From the user POV Apple Pay vs IAP is almost the same flow.
Re:The Art of the Possible by scarface74 on Sunday June 21, 2020 @09:06AM (#23591801)
Why is it so surprising that a retailer wants to make a profit when they sell something in their store?

A developer is free to offer subscriptions both in and out of the App Store and charge 43% more in the store to make up for the 30% cut.

The idea that it is almost the same flow is good for the consumer and developer. For none digital goods, this is already possible and allowed - to use Apple Pay within an app.

I do it with Uber.

Re:The Art of the Possible by jiofih on Sunday June 21, 2020 @07:01PM (#23596039)
So you have no qualms with paying 30% more just for the convenience of doing it in-app? Would you feel ok finding out afterwards that you’d save $40 by not paying with Apple? It’s a shitty consumer experience either way (not having the option, or paying more).
Re:The Art of the Possible by scarface74 on Monday June 22, 2020 @12:04PM (#23601736)
Well, there are a lot of places where consumers pay more for convenience. In fact, you almost always pay more for items in “convenience stores”. You even pay more for the cold drink in the check out isle at grocery store than you do for the same amount of drink in the aisle.

How much more do you pay for recessions at the movie theater than by going to the dollar store before hand and putting the candy in your or your SO’s purse?

I’ve found out later that I could get items cheaper by doing comparison shopping all the time. There are also times I purposefully pay more for convenience.