News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Freedom of Speech: A Right for Everybody, or Only for Lik... by honkycat on Friday June 19, 2020 @12:56PM (#23576312)
> From a meta standpoint, it's interesting to me that the most vociferous deniers of free speech throughout history have made some version of the case "But they're wrong!" (You can add stupid, evil, whatnot. The point is that whatever they're saying, it should not be said because it is not correct)

All of them did, huh? Interesting.

> Whereas folks supporting free speech have made the argument: maybe I'm wrong. I don't know everything, and I've been wrong before.

Did they though? Or are you constructing a strawman argument portraying the "anti free-speech" side as dumb and the "pro free-speech" side as reasonable?

[dead]
Re:Freedom of Speech: A Right for Everybody, or Only for Lik... by happytoexplain on Friday June 19, 2020 @02:02PM (#23577151)
>Certainly all the anti free speech arguments I've encountered are either dumb or evil. But maybe that's on me

Yes, it is on you. If you find yourself in such an absolutist situation, you can bet money that you are in the wrong. It doesn't help that you have grouped all these "evil" and "dumb" opinions under the umbrella of "anti free-speech". That's an absurd exaggeration. Of course an opinion that is "anti free-speech" without any qualification would be dumb or evil.

Re:Freedom of Speech: A Right for Everybody, or Only for Lik... by klyrs on Friday June 19, 2020 @02:05PM (#23577197)
> Perhaps some people against free speech don't even claim that the people they want to silence are wrong. Is that better?

That's an interesting spin on "people have limited tolerance of free speech, when that speech is flagrantly intolerant." The argument is that tangible and quantifiable harm can arise from certain utterances. Such speech is not "wrong" per se, but a violation of the principle that your right to swing your fist ends where my nose begins.

Re:Freedom of Speech: A Right for Everybody, or Only for Lik... by dependenttypes on Friday June 19, 2020 @03:40PM (#23578154)
People have limited tolerance of free speech even when free speech is more tolerant than their own opinions.
Re:Freedom of Speech: A Right for Everybody, or Only for Lik... by klyrs on Friday June 19, 2020 @06:33PM (#23579533)
> What is up with people just ignoring the content of the message that they are replying to and either repeating what they said before or reply to something that was never said? This seems to be more and more common in HN these days.
Re:Freedom of Speech: A Right for Everybody, or Only for Lik... by dependenttypes on Friday June 19, 2020 @07:52PM (#23580135)
Yes? What does this have to do with my post? Do you enjoy going through people's posts and making random quotes that do not fit the current topic?
Re:Freedom of Speech: A Right for Everybody, or Only for Lik... by klyrs on Saturday June 20, 2020 @01:29AM (#23581938)
You ducked my point entirely.
Re:Freedom of Speech: A Right for Everybody, or Only for Lik... by dependenttypes on Saturday June 20, 2020 @02:16AM (#23582141)
Sure, I was interested in addressing the "people have limited tolerance of free speech, when that speech is flagrantly intolerant." specifically rather than your main argument. I do not think that I repeated any argument nor replied to something that was never said nor do I think that this debunks your main argument.
Re:Freedom of Speech: A Right for Everybody, or Only for Lik... by klyrs on Saturday June 20, 2020 @02:31PM (#23585722)
There's a razor in use; I advocate tolerance of speech up to the line of intolerant speech.

Yes, people are intolerant of all sorts of speech and expression which are perfectly harmless and protected speech. E.g. gay people kissing in a movie is "not family friendly" whereas straight people kissing is downright expected. Or, people being harrassed for wearing their symbols of faith in public, etc. That's speech and expression that aren't harmful, though they do offend bigots -- there's no demonstrable harm in those expressions, and the offended can piss right off. (edit: harrassing is not free speech; wearing symbols of faith is)

What I was referring to as intolerance is hate speech. Calling for violence, denegrating a class of people, etc. There, real and demonstrable harm is done.

You "debunked" the least generous interpretation of my statement, and thereby completely avoided the point.

Re:Freedom of Speech: A Right for Everybody, or Only for Lik... by honkycat on Friday June 19, 2020 @01:11PM (#23576541)
You are moving the goal post but if you are really so ill-informed about this issue, I will go ahead and give you an example:

If a well funded group of people are publishing information about a minority group in order to incite and justify genocide, like what we have seen happen on Facebook in Myanmar, I think the rights of the people being massacred should trump the rights of the genocidal's free speech.

Is that argument dumb or evil?

Re:Freedom of Speech: A Right for Everybody, or Only for Lik... by throwawaygh on Friday June 19, 2020 @02:40PM (#23577564)
> Is that argument dumb or evil?

As a pro-free-speech advocate, I think that argument is important and smart and good.

Free speech does have disadvantages, and those disadvantages can have serious consequences.

The attempt to hand-wave those disadvantages away with "but enough people will just be perfectly rational and care about truth, and then all those good people who love truth will prevent genocide!" is... extraordinarily naive.

Whether to support free speech is a question of weighing advantages and disadvantages. I happen to think the advantages far outweigh the disadvantages. But if you seriously can't see any of the disadvantages, and can't empathize with a person who reasons that those disadvantages outweigh the advantages, then you're probably not thinking clearly enough.

Re:Freedom of Speech: A Right for Everybody, or Only for Lik... by user982 on Friday June 19, 2020 @01:51PM (#23577018)
"But what if the genociders are right?"
Re:Freedom of Speech: A Right for Everybody, or Only for Lik... by dependenttypes on Friday June 19, 2020 @03:39PM (#23578131)
Saying "but what if the gays are not that bad" 70 years ago would get you labelled a lot of things and censored. Same thing happens now in certain countries.
Re:Freedom of Speech: A Right for Everybody, or Only for Lik... by user982 on Friday June 19, 2020 @03:49PM (#23578231)
So your response is "But what if the genociders are right?", but unironically.
Re:Freedom of Speech: A Right for Everybody, or Only for Lik... by dependenttypes on Friday June 19, 2020 @04:54PM (#23578770)