News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by boudewijnrempt on Friday June 19, 2020 @10:48AM (#23575056)
When Microsoft helped me get Krita in the Windows Store I hadn't much expectations. Now the Windows Store and Steam (fifty/fifty) bring in enough to pay me and six other people to work on Krita almost full-time. It has saved me from having to find a day job that would have driven me round the bend for sure.

That said, it sucks that I cannot tell people they can also download Krita from krita.org. There's always the fear that some day, the Windows Store will be closed, or Krita will be kicked out or whatever.

Publishing in an app store means you're a sharecropper, with all that entails.

Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by nico_h on Friday June 19, 2020 @12:33PM (#23576043)
Yeah, that's the thing that's so annoying about at least the windows (TIL) and Apple App Store: you cannot mention any other option.

If they were so confident in the convenience they offered they would allow you to mention other options. This reeks of anti-competitiveness.

Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by jfoster on Friday June 19, 2020 @12:56PM (#23576309)
Their fears seem mostly unfounded, too. For most consumers, the convenience of an app store is massive.
Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by sneak on Friday June 19, 2020 @01:06PM (#23576461)
The issue, I think, is not that Apple sets draconian rules in their store. Their store, their rules.

It's that I, a user, cannot choose to sideload an app I want to use on my device or choose to use a different store.

Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by Sir_Substance on Friday June 19, 2020 @08:21PM (#23580329)
>It's that I, a user, cannot choose to sideload an app

That's only half the equation. I run android, but have no google account. I have always used a combination of aptoide, f-droid and manually downloaded apk's for my apps.

When all the covid apps were released and governments were encouraging people to download them, do you think they put the APK on a government website for people to download?

Nope, just links to the app store. Of course, most of those apps relied on google play services API's for a bunch of stuff, so it's not like they would have worked anyway.

It's not enough to merely allow sideloading. If the expectation isn't that mobile devices are a diverse ecosystem and that it's not good enough for developers to pick one store and bugger the rest, you've achieved very little. Most people could not be bothered going through what I do to keep my phone clean.

Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by sneak on Friday June 19, 2020 @08:48PM (#23580503)
It is very troubling that to use public services, one must agree to an arbitrary and abusive private company contractual agreement (TOS).
Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by Sir_Substance on Sunday June 21, 2020 @07:38AM (#23591441)
I've not yet found that to be the case, although I fear that one day it will.

I generally find that all you need to do is tell people their solution is not acceptable. All the banks in Iceland are trying really hard to convince people that phone based 2FA is the only option. However, I went to my bank and informed them that I don't take my phone with me when I travel overseas and I require another option. They tried a few other variations of "but you could use your phone this way", but once they realized I wasn't joking when I said "I often just don't have a phone with me, find me something else" it turns out that the physical 2FA tokens totally still work, they just don't like telling people.

Generally speaking, the people providing these things have a boss who expects them to make sure things run smoothly. They'll try to force you to use the app if that's the easiest path, but as soon as they realise that trying to force you to use the app will be much more painful for them than just giving you another option, they'll find another option.

Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by dathinab on Friday June 19, 2020 @02:03PM (#23577168)
What should be possible is not to sidenote an app but an entry app store.
Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by thephyber on Friday June 19, 2020 @05:04PM (#23578841)
This also happens in credit card merchant contracts (from what I've read) and it seems like the kind of thing that I prefer governments regulate (rather than try to disrupt all app stores altogether).

I just want to know that my license to use an app purchased in 1 store means that the license follows me (or my account or my estate, etc), not limited to that one app store. If I buy a game on Steam, and later move to a PS and later move to XBox, I don't want the loss of value associated with losing all copies of my legally purchased/licensed content (or worse, if my account is closed/banned on one platform).

This is also what is destroying any potential value to electronic health records (although doctors seem to hate transcribing their notes, so the value may be limited anyway).

Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by manquer on Saturday June 20, 2020 @11:47AM (#23584555)
You can say there are options in a credit card enabled business . What You cannot do is make cash transfer cheaper by offering to reducing the price by the cut you pay the provider.

It is not a lock-in at all, and it also not strictly enforced or enforceable even , plenty of times I have given cash when a vendor offered me a 2 % discount on a large purchase where the extra hassle was worth it .

Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by thephyber on Monday June 22, 2020 @09:55PM (#23609193)
> it also not strictly enforced or enforceable even

Your assertion seems to be that just because you got away with it that it's "not enforceable". I would argue that just because it's a clause in a merchant contract (a very important contract for a small business), it's a significant threat.

Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by manquer on Friday June 26, 2020 @12:48AM (#23648819)
I meant enforceable legally depending on the jurisdiction not practically.

The comparison is not the same at all, No merchant gateway is blocking cash transactions just forbid different pricing.

This is miles away from what Apple can do. A payment g/w can only at best stop payment processing as it happened wikileaks or more recently with SciHub.

Apple can kick you off the market effectively by blocking access to app store . Either the app store should be treated like a utility given its monopolistic nature or not be allowed to push their second service (payment g/w, lots of competition) because they have control over first one App store (no competition), in another era this would be classic anti-trust .

Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by orky56 on Friday June 19, 2020 @01:43PM (#23576936)
When you have a stronghold, it makes more sense to build an ever larger moat.
Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by Tade0 on Friday June 19, 2020 @11:57AM (#23575729)
Recently friend of mine told me he bought Krita through the Windows app store - I was confused because I thought it was free. Thanks for the clarification.

BTW big fan of this app and I have to admit that I'm relieved that it has some sort of a steady revenue stream. That sum next to the Donate button doesn't look like it could sustain any large scale development.

Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by boudewijnrempt on Friday June 19, 2020 @06:01PM (#23579299)
Currently, we're making about 16k a month, and that's funding six people. The donations fund the seventh person.
Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by AdmiralAsshat on Friday June 19, 2020 @11:01AM (#23575175)
> That said, it sucks that I cannot tell people they can also download Krita from krita.org.

As in, you've signed an NDA literally forbidding you from mentioning as such? Or you're simply not allowed to put the URL anywhere in the Windows Store description?

Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by gganley on Friday June 19, 2020 @11:11AM (#23575258)
The second option, keep in mind speaking from reading and not from experience
Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by rnotaro on Friday June 19, 2020 @03:06PM (#23577829)
False. The URL is currently in the Microsoft Store description.

https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/p/krita/9n6x57zgrw96

Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by dapole on Friday June 19, 2020 @03:09PM (#23577861)
I mean in practice you can also list links to your site on the Apple App Store but you aren’t allowed to mention a cheaper price or another purchasing option.
Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by thephyber on Friday June 19, 2020 @05:08PM (#23578879)
It seems to me there is some price arbitrage opportunity for a 3rd party who can figure out how to get affiliate payments.

If the app developer can't advertise that one of their store options is cheaper, a 3rd party isn't limited by the same contractual obligation.

Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by jaywalk on Friday June 19, 2020 @11:12AM (#23575269)
I'd imagine it's more that Microsoft takes a smaller cut if they come to the store via krita.org versus finding it through the store itself, so they don't want to give that up.
Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by httpsterio on Friday June 19, 2020 @11:38AM (#23575513)
Krita on Windows' store costs (I think) around 10 dollars. Directly from Krita's site, 0 dollars. Windows has a similar policy as Apple that the app creators cannot tell the users on the store page to go somewhere else to get it cheaper/free.
Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by ehsankia on Friday June 19, 2020 @12:05PM (#23575814)
The commenter above was making a slightly different point. Some digital stores take a large cut if the user finds the app organically while browsing their Store, vs if they came to the store page from a link on the owner's site.

The former means Windows helped the user find the app, whereas the latter means the author did and Microsoft is just providing a way for the user to download the app.

Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by Talanes on Friday June 19, 2020 @12:36PM (#23576078)
Which stores? Does the Microsoft store work this way? When you respond to a specific and pointed question with theoretical knowledge of how things "could work," it just starts to muddy the waters.
Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by lostmsu on Friday June 19, 2020 @01:11PM (#23576533)
That is how Microsoft Store works, yes.

In my app most downloads are from direct links, so I am happy about that policy.

Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by ehsankia on Friday June 19, 2020 @01:32PM (#23576819)
Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by ViViDboarder on Friday June 19, 2020 @12:03PM (#23575798)
Which makes sense. If they find it through the store, they’ve played a role in acquiring that user.

How do they stand on subscriptions though? That’s one of the areas that Apple has been terrible with.

Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by dathinab on Friday June 19, 2020 @02:07PM (#23577219)
> which makes sense

But what if the user literally just enters the apps name in the search. In this case the app store only played the negligible role of an trivial looking indeed. Is it really reasonable to then thanks a larger cut?

Edit: but then the cut for extremely driven aquisation is 5% which compared to some other stores is really low. So I really shouldn't complain ;)

Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by sergeykish on Friday June 19, 2020 @12:20PM (#23575935)
It sounds so convoluted. Like providing service for customers is not enough. Applications is the reason people use Windows.

Paying customers may be product too.

Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by rtsil on Friday June 19, 2020 @12:46PM (#23576187)
> Paying customers may be product too.

That was implied ever since Microsoft decided to make Windows 10 free or at a very low cost to a majority of users. And, why not, as long as their fee is not outrageous for application developers and they don't restrict the users' ability to install software from other sources.

Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by sergeykish on Friday June 19, 2020 @12:58PM (#23576343)
It is not free https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/store/b/windows

So paying yet product. And varying price is something I would expect from airlines, not from respectable business.

Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by rtsil on Friday June 19, 2020 @05:44PM (#23579161)
> It is not free https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/store/b/windows

Most people either upgraded for free to a new version (the same operation was paid before), or get Windows through a subsidized OEM version. Subsidized is pretty clear: you pay less, in exchange for something else.

> varying price is something I would expect from airlines, not from respectable business.

Why should we expect a software company to be more ethical, for varying definitions of ethical, than an airline company?

Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by gmanley on Friday June 19, 2020 @02:14PM (#23577287)
When it was released they offered a free upgrade. You are still able to use the same method to upgrade for free: https://www.cnet.com/how-to/how-to-download-windows-10-for-f...
Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by sergeykish on Friday June 19, 2020 @02:47PM (#23577632)
Free upgrade from paid product to paid product. Still paying yet product.

I question wisdom of the original term. What if "shut up and take money" is not enough? If so was it on purpose or by accident? First time in my life I think of conspiracy theories.

My take on catchy phrases:

- You are a product for for-profit

- You are a product if don't fight for your freedoms

Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by blackoil on Friday June 19, 2020 @11:36AM (#23575494)
Download link is prominent(in top header) on krita.org ?? Do you mean you are not allowed to add link from Windows Store description. Which seems reasonable, i.e. equivalent of using Amazon to promote company site (alternate/competing store).
Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by vageli on Friday June 19, 2020 @03:29PM (#23578040)
Would you feel similarly about AirBnB hosts leaving their contact information in the physical location so you could arrange bookings outside the platform? Just curious because I can see the value platforms provide in discovery and "bringing the customers to you" but once you have proved your worth to the customer, it's not clear to me why a platform-middleman is still needed.
Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by jobigoud on Friday June 19, 2020 @12:34PM (#23576058)
It feels a bit like a dark pattern though if you consider a user that find it first through the store. I would like to know the percentage of users that consciously paid for it knowing they could also download it for free vs those users that paid for it because they didn't know better.
Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by kohtatsu on Friday June 19, 2020 @02:45PM (#23577613)
Agreed. I imagine a lot of the blindsided users would be wary of using the Microsoft Store thereafter.
Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by i2shar on Friday June 19, 2020 @02:23PM (#23577398)
I wasn't aware of Krita before, checked it out after I read comments here. I now have a much deeper appreciation of animation artists. One scene is so much work! [1] And kudos to you for making your tool available for free.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9diKUhxImqo

Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by bebna on Friday June 19, 2020 @11:30AM (#23575435)
I don't think that don't matters that much atm. Most will google for paint programm or directly for krita after they heard about from somewhere (youtube tuts for example) and land on the project homepage. After which they mostly will remember to look for the homepage next time they install it again.
Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by femiagbabiaka on Friday June 19, 2020 @02:15PM (#23577298)
It’s definitely not all that it entails, but point taken. Anyways, I prefer the open web instinctively, but it would be interesting to see data on the average age of software on the internet alongside where that software is hosted.
Re:Microsoft calls for a closer look at app stores by mycall on Saturday June 20, 2020 @12:47PM (#23584910)
Do you have any plans to make a VR version of Krita? I would love to hang and paint with it's capabilities in 3D space.