Re:Zombie Satellites Return from the Graveyard
by Monroe13 on Friday June 19, 2020 @09:44AM
(#23574438)
According to some Wikipedia research “De-orbiting a geostationary satellite requires a delta-v of about 1,500 metres per second (4,900 ft/s), whereas re-orbiting it to a graveyard orbit only requires about 11 metres per second (36 ft/s).”
Re:Zombie Satellites Return from the Graveyard
by raxxorrax on Monday June 22, 2020 @10:25AM
(#23600515)
Huh, wouldn't have guessed it to be that much, but it makes sense. De-orbiting gets cheaper the higher your orbit is and a geo stationary orbit is high, but not that high.
Re:Zombie Satellites Return from the Graveyard
by walrus01 on Friday June 19, 2020 @12:06PM
(#23575821)
While theoretically possible, it is a lot easier to put a "spare" 1500-2000m/s of delta v and fuel tankage on a Kerbal spacecraft than in real life. Unless we invent a magical ion thruster with a specific impulse of 30000 nobody is going to put enough fuel on a Geostationary telecom satellite to lower its perigee below 100km at EOL. That same fuel is better used for station keeping and to extend its service life.
Re:Zombie Satellites Return from the Graveyard
by xenophonf on Friday June 19, 2020 @11:39AM
(#23575520)
The Kerbal way is to remember that to lower your orbit, you have to slow down, and to slow down requires propellant. You're moving really, really fast in a geosync orbit, so slowing down to lithobrake your satellite would require a _lot_ of propellant.
Conversely, to raise your orbit, you have to speed up. And since you're only going up a little bit, you only need a little bit of propellant.
Re:Zombie Satellites Return from the Graveyard
by gameswithgo on Friday June 19, 2020 @09:49AM
(#23574490)
requires a huge amount of fuel for a geo-stat-sat to get back down.
Are the satelites too large to burn up?