Re:Zombie Satellites Return from the Graveyard
by sohkamyung on Friday June 19, 2020 @05:48AM
(#23572828)
Maybe I'm wrong, but the Van Allen belts may also be a reason [1]. The ISS and LEO is below the belts, but the geostationary orbit is inside them, which might cause astronauts to be exposed to higher levels of solar radiation.
Re:Zombie Satellites Return from the Graveyard
by Robotbeat on Thursday June 18, 2020 @09:49PM
(#23570206)
Humans have done something like repairs on telecom satellites... If they got stuck in LEO before insertion to GEO. Also, ISS.
Re:Zombie Satellites Return from the Graveyard
by walrus01 on Thursday June 18, 2020 @10:23PM
(#23570393)
Very, very rarely and at ridiculous cost ($900m+ per launch) by space shuttle in the 1980s as publicity stunts, nothing more.
Re:Zombie Satellites Return from the Graveyard
by WalterBright on Thursday June 18, 2020 @11:40PM
(#23570717)
The space telescope got several repair and upgrade missions.
Since the R+D cost of developing the telescope was already spent, it's hard to believe the incremental cost of building and launching another one would have cost more than a shuttle mission.
Re:Zombie Satellites Return from the Graveyard
by walrus01 on Thursday June 18, 2020 @11:44PM
(#23570744)
LEO is a very, very different thing in terms of exo-atmospheric delta v budget than achieving a circular Geostationary distance orbit with a manned craft.
Re:Zombie Satellites Return from the Graveyard
by Cthulhu_ on Friday June 19, 2020 @08:25AM
(#23573751)
Which is why I really hope the new space telescope will work, since they can't realistically go out there to fix it.
Re:Zombie Satellites Return from the Graveyard
by ufmace on Friday June 19, 2020 @11:09AM
(#23575247)
And then having enough fuel leftover to return to Earth from Geostationary orbit with your manned craft.
Re:Zombie Satellites Return from the Graveyard
by walrus01 on Friday June 19, 2020 @11:56AM
(#23575716)
And having a craft that can survive the heat load of re-entering the atmosphere from very high speed (as they demoed in an Orion test flight unmanned), if you're in Geostationary and thrust retrograde until your orbit becomes a highly elliptical one with a new perigee of around 100km, you're going to re-enter very hot and fast.
Re:Zombie Satellites Return from the Graveyard
by Robotbeat on Saturday June 20, 2020 @03:46PM
(#23586589)
The marginal costs for Shuttle missions were less than that, say about $250 million, and they often launched multiple satellites as well as performing other missions. Itβs complicated.
Re:Zombie Satellites Return from the Graveyard
by walrus01 on Saturday June 20, 2020 @07:19PM
(#23588282)
The total cost of the space shuttle program in 2011, adjusted for inflation was $196 billion. It launched a total of 135 times. This is about 1.45 billion per launch.
Re:Zombie Satellites Return from the Graveyard
by onion2k on Friday June 19, 2020 @10:02AM
(#23574603)
One of the things persons not involved in the industry find interesting, is that in the entire history of manned spaceflight, no human has ever visited geostationary orbit.
No one has ever stopped in geostationary orbit, but you have to go past where geostationary satellites stay to get to the moon, so quite a lot of people have really.
Re:Zombie Satellites Return from the Graveyard
by emiliobumachar on Friday June 19, 2020 @10:42AM
(#23574992)
Excuse my meta-pedantry, but an orbit is not defined only by a height, it requires also an appropriate velocity.
Re:Zombie Satellites Return from the Graveyard
by walrus01 on Friday June 19, 2020 @11:53AM
(#23575672)
Well yes, you certainly wouldn't want to go to a circular geostationary orbit and then expend a ton of fuel to thrust retrograde, cancelling out all your velocity, which would result in falling straight into the earth. Definitely not like people would think of in common sci-fi where things can just hang motionless in space.
Being in circular geostationary is defined as also having enough velocity for your orbit to remain circular.
Re:Zombie Satellites Return from the Graveyard
by walrus01 on Friday June 19, 2020 @11:50AM
(#23575639)
Trajectories on the way to/from the moon would require a lot of additional delta v to circularize at Geostationary. Or if you're in an orbit that looks like 550 km x 37600 km, when you're at apogee you need a lot of extra delta v spent in prograde thrust to raise your perigee to the same figure.
I have talked to a number of people who were mistakenly under the impression that humans occasionally conduct repairs on telecom satellites.
Also this is the first time a (non-classified, that we know about) spacecraft has visited and photographed another satellite in geostationary orbit.