If it doesn't have backdoors now, it will soon. The remote-intercept capability mandate for land line phones is in the process of being extended to all commercial VOIP.
> Hardware-only plug & play box will never work here.
This looks like an example:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Secure_Terminal_Equipment
Or, for that matter, this:
http://www.gdc4s.com/content/detail.cfm?item=32640fd9-0213-4...
> I don't think you can prove any of it
Naturally.
But the absence of any easy-to-use/uncrackable/provably non-backdoored secure voice phone on the market is proof enough for me.
If you have to worry about being monitored by government, a super secret phone will not help you anyways. If it's worth doing, your room / furniture / clothes / windows are already bugged and all you say will be recorded before it hits the phone. I really think a provably secure phone is a non-issue.
The worth of the phone is to prevent you from turning into someone who ought to worry in the first place.
Bugging room / furniture / clothes / windows is expensive.
The NSA is known to use voice recognition and keyword search. It is no longer necessary to already be a target in order to be extensively and intelligently eavesdropped on.
Hardware-only plug & play box will never work here. You actually have to know something about the connection - information provided out of band. And I don't think most people would accept pressing ~150 digits on the pad as an easy solution.
Analog encryption does not end on scramblers and they don't have to be a joke. As mentioned before, put 2 modems together, apply gsm encoding and any digital encryption you want.
There's a lot of FUD here. If you come up with a proper system, black vans will take you away; NSA has gentelman's agreement; your product will disappear from the market; etc. etc. I don't think you can prove any of it and I can't disprove it either, so I'd rather stay with things we can be sure about.