News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Who the Hell Is This Joyce (1928) by Quequau on Thursday June 18, 2020 @05:10AM (#23561253)
100% of my interest in James Joyce comes from Joseph Campbell.

The first time I tried to read Joyce my attempt did not go well because I didn't really understand why Campbell was so taken with these works, so my own expectations about what I was getting into were wildly off the mark.

So I really get where H. G. Wells is coming from. Though I have to admit that Wells' writing is way, way more articulate than my thoughts at the time.

Many years later I got back into Joseph Campbell by way of Julian Jaynes and wound up with Finnegan's Wake again only I suppose with a different set of expectations and perspective. It's still not something I personally would read for idle pleasure but I feel like I'm understanding more of the big picture Joseph Campbell was all about, so it was a worthwhile read.

Re:Who the Hell Is This Joyce (1928) by cgsullivan on Thursday June 18, 2020 @12:45PM (#23564926)
I was in a book club dedicated to reading Finnegans Wake, all 626 pages. We met every two weeks over dinner and would discuss a page or two, or sometimes just a paragraph if things were especially puzzling. It took us eight years to complete.

I agree with Wells about the frustrations with the endless riddles and the incessantly opaque style.

However an unexpected pleasure was how much fun it was to read in a group. For example, a set of allusions sprinkled on the page might catch the eye of someone for whom the subject was a pet interest or hobby, otherwise we all would have missed it. I learned a lot about world history, art, philosophy, etc., and I almost always ended the evening astounded at the oddest bits of information my friends had tucked away in their heads.

Finnegans Wake works really well as a scaffold for learning and conversation; as a story, I'm not so sure, but I think it is a remarkable literary experiment. There are also several truly beautiful passages hidden away in the book, which hit you by complete surprise when you stumble on them.

Re:Who the Hell Is This Joyce (1928) by dtwhitney on Thursday June 18, 2020 @10:00AM (#23563174)
IMHO, Ulysses is worth the time, but I agree about Finnegans Wake
Re:Who the Hell Is This Joyce (1928) by melq on Thursday June 18, 2020 @11:17AM (#23563850)
Also, Dubliners and Portrait of the Artist are excellent and not nearly as dense.