News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Massive spying on users of Google's Chrome shows new secu... by joshuamorton on Thursday June 18, 2020 @04:50AM (#23561127)
You've contradicted yourself in the first 3 lines.

> At the same time, back in 2016 a study at Princeton found almost 50% of all sites on the web had Doubleclick tracking on the

Means that many people are going to doubleclick, via it's ads existing on other sites. If the extent of your concern is that I said "going to" instead of "makes requests to", valid and I apologise for not being precise in my use of language.

However, the HN guidelines also ask that you respond to the strongest possible interpretation of what someone is saying. So please respond to what it is clear I meant, and not the straw man you feel compelled to attack.

And since that bit of rhetorical drama seems to at this point be the core of your concern, I don't know that theres anything of substance for me to address here, just more personal attacks.

> My browser "sneakily in the background goes to double click" while I browse about half the sites on the internet.

To be clear, this is false. Your browser isn't doing anything sneaky here. Perhaps you can argue that individual websites are being sneaky by including 3p advertising. That's a valid concern. But a browser "loading the HTML of the page you direct it to" isn't being sneaky or nefarious.

Re:Massive spying on users of Google's Chrome shows new secu... by bigiain on Thursday June 18, 2020 @04:56AM (#23561178)
And how many times did your mom say she "went to" or "made requests to" doubleclick today?

We all know the answer. Zero. Whatever your sneaky-browser-behaviour-depending employer wants you to say in public, her answer will be zero. Same as 99.99% of the world.

Re:Massive spying on users of Google's Chrome shows new secu... by raxxorrax on Thursday June 18, 2020 @10:18AM (#23563329)
I hope there is generally less rationalization at Google towards privacy practices to be honest.

I think the behavior on display is pretty sneaky, undermines privacy and users aren't really informed about Google doing "research" on them.

Re:Massive spying on users of Google's Chrome shows new secu... by joshuamorton on Thursday June 18, 2020 @01:07PM (#23565172)
This is a fair comment. I'm not saying that there couldn't be better privacy practices in place (while I think Google is better than average here, we aren' perfect and to your point I think a lot of people within Google recognize that).

But the question here is what part of this is sneaky? Is including a weird tracking header sneaky? Perhaps. Is making requests to doubleclick sneaky? In the context of those requests being made as part of a page load? Not on the part of Google, which is my point.

The original complaint was that the header was being sent

> That Google need to send "experimental headers" to a hardcoded domain for an advertising company they bought a decade or so back - because of course the results of web browser experiments should go to an advertising company

And the reason why is simple: that's the domain people are already making requests to.