News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Assorted improvements to News.YC by pg on Thursday July 03, 2008 @04:01PM (#235581)
Don't be misled by the use of the word "vote." Upvotes are not like an election or poll. They're really 1-bit comments.
Re:Assorted improvements to News.YC by gojomo on Thursday July 03, 2008 @05:31PM (#235691)
I know that's your intent, but each wave of new users is only going to pick that up slowly -- if ever.

And it's not just the word 'vote' that's a problem. The UI/functionality doesn't completely support that intent: they're "comments" that can be erased when the next person votes the other way. They're reported like a poll -- a summary number. But downvotes sting more than respectful disagreement, because they imply transgression.

The coarsening of discussion, the anguish over piling-on, the long threads about proper voting, the karmic games -- they're all worsened because the 1-bit message 'this comment is bad' and the 1-bit message 'I disagree' are forced into a single 1-bit channel.

(Forcing "this comment is good" and "I agree" in the same channel isn't problematic the same way, because neither sentiment conveys opprobrium and triggers defensiveness.)