News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A look at the die of the 8086 processor by Taniwha on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @05:12PM (#23556821)
I suspect that at the time microcode was copyrightable while masks (and therefore PLAs) were not (note the actual (C) message on the die explicitly calling out the microcode)
Re:A look at the die of the 8086 processor by kens on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @07:21PM (#23558017)
Protection for "mask works" was introduced in the Semiconductor Chip Protection act of 1984. You'll see a circled-M on modern dies indicating this protection. (I got the mask work symbol added to Unicode recently, but font support is lacking: 🆭.) The 8086 is the only chip I've seen with a copyright specifically designating the microcode.
Re:A look at the die of the 8086 processor by pwg on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @05:27PM (#23556988)
In the context of IC chip layouts, the determining factor is almost always die area. Some functions will be smaller on the die in PLA form, other functions will be smaller on the die in microcode form. Since die area is almost always a scarce resource, the chip designer will usually pick the design that reduces die area consumption for any given function.
Re:A look at the die of the 8086 processor by Taniwha on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @05:51PM (#23557219)
(puts on chip designer hat) yes and no, as I said upstream the copyright laws of the time did not protect designs, chip copying (stealing) was rampant.

I can imagine that some CPU designers from a particular world view (especially in the 70s) might only design in terms of microcode - but also design tools were pretty minimal, I can imagine that it might have been far easier to design things in terms of microcode rather than as PLAs - what you might be seeing here is the differences between different teams' in house custom tooling

Re:A look at the die of the 8086 processor by miohtama on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @06:40PM (#23557659)
Is 8086 microcode reverse engineered or released today for studying?
Re:A look at the die of the 8086 processor by kiwidrew on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @10:05PM (#23559057)
Not yet, but with these new high-resolution die photos it is only a matter of time.

Meanwhile the US4449184 patent [1] referenced in the post's footnotes has a lot of information about how the microcode works (and the meaning of the 21 instruction bits) and, in Tables 7-12, shows the microcode listings for some of the microcoded 8086 instructions.

[1] https://patents.google.com/patent/US4449184

Re:A look at the die of the 8086 processor by Taniwha on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @07:09PM (#23557919)
probably not, but the data from this project should make that pretty easy

However to be useful you need to know what each of those 21-bits is connected to, some will essentially be risc-like uCode instructions, the others will be tied to particular functions in the CPU or memory interface