Re:Americans today are 60% richer than their parents
by yummyfajitas on Tuesday March 22, 2011 @02:16PM
(#2355614)
If you want to quibble over the definition of "rich", be my guest.
To maintain a middle class lifestyle, one must today make a proportionally far larger expenditure for housing, education and transportation.
Only if you take a definition of middle class which has inflated faster than economic growth. I.e., if you are 60% richer (in terms of income) than your parents, but you define "middle class" to be 80% richer, indeed it is more difficult to be middle class. This does not change the fact that most people have higher income than their parents.
Also, you are misrepresenting Warren's data (admittedly, she presents it in a very confusing way). The primary necessity which reduces discretionary income is taxes, not housing, child care or automotive expenses.
In Warren's hypothetical, income increased 75%, mortgage expenses by 70% (for a 66% bigger house [1]), two cars in 2010 cost 55% more than 1 car in 1970, and health insurance increased 60%. The biggest increase in expenses was tax, which increased 140%. In dollar terms, the tax increase was larger than the cost increases in housing, automotive and health insurance expenses combined.
By the way, did you notice that Warren claims household wealth increased? I.e., the family has 66% more house and 100% more cars? (Not to mention better health care, an XBox, etc.)
To maintain a middle class lifestyle, one must today make a proportionally far larger expenditure for housing, education and transportation.
Only if you take a definition of middle class which has inflated faster than economic growth. I.e., if you are 60% richer (in terms of income) than your parents, but you define "middle class" to be 80% richer, indeed it is more difficult to be middle class. This does not change the fact that most people have higher income than their parents.
Also, you are misrepresenting Warren's data (admittedly, she presents it in a very confusing way). The primary necessity which reduces discretionary income is taxes, not housing, child care or automotive expenses.
In Warren's hypothetical, income increased 75%, mortgage expenses by 70% (for a 66% bigger house [1]), two cars in 2010 cost 55% more than 1 car in 1970, and health insurance increased 60%. The biggest increase in expenses was tax, which increased 140%. In dollar terms, the tax increase was larger than the cost increases in housing, automotive and health insurance expenses combined.
http://www.volokh.com/posts/1185883980.shtml
http://volokh.com/archives/archive_2008_04_27-2008_05_03.sht...
By the way, did you notice that Warren claims household wealth increased? I.e., the family has 66% more house and 100% more cars? (Not to mention better health care, an XBox, etc.)
[1] http://www.realtor.org/RMODaily.nsf/pages/News2007032701?Ope...