News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Correct Horse Battery Staple password generator by pkhamre on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @05:21AM (#23537273)
So you're saying that generating a new password looses entropy?
Re:Show HN: Correct Horse Battery Staple password generator by mlaci on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @09:55AM (#23539143)
Yes, if the regeneration depends on your preference of the generated words, the words order or link between them. The individual generations independent from each other, so if your choice – how many regeneration you do - not depends on the generations outcome, for example on your birthday date or favorite number, their randomness are equal.

But randomness are not enough, it's possible the first generated version correlate with your preference and that situation does not really matter why are you stopped generating new password.

Predictability of this scheme very good, because the strict rules. All implementation using common english words. For words smaller length, easy spelling, less ambiguity are preferred. Mixing nouns verbs and adjectives are more meaningful, order also adds more meaning. Word count very limited. Preference on the separator character also very rigid. Personal preference more known, because hidding your preference on all english words very hard and mostly unconscious.

Re:Show HN: Correct Horse Battery Staple password generator by setr on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @05:38AM (#23537325)
Choosing is the problem here -- it's now only as random as your preference

Eg the scheme doesn't do its job well if you don't know the word, so the dictionary can be reduced by that much

Re:Show HN: Correct Horse Battery Staple password generator by ResidentSleeper on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @07:17AM (#23537797)
On the other hand, I'd wager that the set of words that you can recognize is vastly larger than the set of words that you're likely to come up with on the spot. Hence, using a generator would still result in higher entropy then trying to come up with a password yourself.

Random numbers picked by humans are notoriously biased. I'm guessing it's even worse when you ask them to come up with random words.