News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court endorses gay, transgender worker prote... by pdonis on Monday June 15, 2020 @05:13PM (#23533046)
> it's as if you're telling me what a piece of code does by reading the comments.

Hm, interesting analogy. I see your point, but I think I would put it a bit differently. See below.

> apparently muttering the correct words is sufficient to satisfy people on the right, why change things?

Where did I say I was satisfied? (Assuming for the sake of argument that I am "on the right", which I actually don't think is true, but that's an argument for another time.) I'm not satisfied. I think that achieving a short-term policy goal, even a good one, by means not allowed by the plain language of the Constitution is bad long-term policy. The fact that sophistry is used to make it appear that the means of achieving the short-term policy goal are in fact in accordance with the Constitution does not make the means actually correct.

In other words, in my view, what the Court has done here is not upholding the rule of law. Saying that "well, the law is whatever the Court says it is" does not make it true. If, as you say, everyone knows quite well that the Civil Rights Act of 1964 did not actually outlaw discrimination because of sexual orientation or transgender, then the Court saying that it actually did is not the rule of law. It's just an arbitrary exercise of power. Arbitrary exercises of power do not change the law. They just mean the government is operating outside the law.

To frame this using your coding analogy, we don't have comments getting out of sync with code, we have two different pieces of code getting out of sync with each other. The code the government is running that it labels "law" is not the same as the code that citizens are running that tells them what the law actually is and whether or not the government is actually upholding it. The code the citizens are running might be based on their reading of "comments" like the Constitution, but that just underscores the fact that those "comments" aren't really just comments--they have actual effects in the world, like giving citizens a basis for making their own judgments about what the law is that they are supposed to be following. If the government gets out of sync with that, that's a problem.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court endorses gay, transgender worker prote... by erichocean on Monday June 15, 2020 @06:15PM (#23533704)
> To frame this using your coding analogy, we don't have comments getting out of sync with code, we have two different pieces of code getting out of sync with each other.

I get what you're saying and agree, actually. That said, it's pretty clear to me that whatever code that you're thinking of isn't running anywhere but in the minds of (mostly White) voters. It's almost completely absent from all forms of government except, perhaps, local governments in rural areas. Trump occasionally makes gestures in that direction but takes no action, as far as I can tell.

The people in power everywhere are running the piece of code that produced today's Supreme Court decision, and are overjoyed with the results.

A more interesting question is, why do we have two separate codes that are out of sync? And what should we do about it (if anything)? But that's too big of a topic for the HN comment section.

Thanks for the back and forth, I appreciate it. :)

Re:U.S. Supreme Court endorses gay, transgender worker prote... by pdonis on Monday June 15, 2020 @08:31PM (#23534686)
> whatever code that you're thinking of isn't running anywhere but in the minds of (mostly White) voters

This might well be true; if it is, it's a sad commentary on our body politic that so many people have lost touch with what the rule of law is supposed to mean. Civilizations where that has happened in the past have not ended well.

> Thanks for the back and forth, I appreciate it. :)

Likewise! :-)