News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court endorses gay, transgender worker prote... by koheripbal on Monday June 15, 2020 @01:04PM (#23529758)
Your argument is invalidated by the fact that apparently "conservative" judges here voted to SUPPORT LGBT rights in this case.

The notion that the Supreme Court is an ideological legislative body is propaganda meant to subvert the integrity of the court.

Some of the most liberally-hated conservative judges, just voted FOR LGBT rights here, because it's they believe it's what the law implies - not because it's what they believe is ethical.

In fact, none of the dissenting opinions said that LGBT people don't deserve the same protections - they simply believed that it's congress's job to make those changes - and that's a hard point to argue honestly.

Sowing partisanship by demonizing the people you disagree with, whilst also undermining the institutions our government is based on is... a really shitty thing to do.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court endorses gay, transgender worker prote... by jawns on Monday June 15, 2020 @09:30PM (#23535041)
7 of 9 justices voted with their respective liberal/conservative blocs and you say my point (that the public perceives the justices as having ideological biases) is invalidated?

Invalidated by the fact that 2 of 9 justices broke ranks in this one particular case? The fact that there are so-called liberal/conservative blocs away from which the justices occasionally break means that yes, there is a common perception that the justices allow their ideological biases to influence their opinions.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court endorses gay, transgender worker prote... by erichocean on Monday June 15, 2020 @01:50PM (#23530514)
> apparently "conservative"

I think you answer your own objection right there. Conservatives don't conserve anything, it's liberalism with a speed limit. The United States doesn't have any party that is interested in conserving anything cultural or legal, anywhere. Which is great for Democrats (like myself).

(There are many conservative voters in both parties, of course, and they would absolutely disagree with this latest ruling. But that's not the same as those voters having a party—there are literally no "conservative" elites in position of power in the Democrat or Republican parties, or anywhere else for that matter. We're effectively at year zero.)

> not because it's what they believe

No, they believe it. The courts are by far the fastest and best means of enacting liberal reforms today. Voters cannot be relied upon to enact these kinds of changes themselves (quite the opposite, in fact—they consistently vote against them). Civil rights legal principles always trump any other law or principle, which is why it's the sole justification for all of these landmark cultural rulings. The Anglo-Saxon legal tradition is as out-of-date with culture today as a statue of George Washington or Thomas Jefferson.

After the courts, we have to rely primarily on finance (private corporations) to push change; Goldman Sachs and assorted hedge funds are incredibly powerful allies in the long march towards progress.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court endorses gay, transgender worker prote... by pdonis on Monday June 15, 2020 @02:31PM (#23531142)
> Which is great for Democrats (like myself)

I find it rather grimly ironic that a political party that calls itself "Democratic" endorses explicitly non democratic means for making reforms, on the grounds that, in your own words, "Voters cannot be relied upon to enact these kinds of changes themselves".

Re:U.S. Supreme Court endorses gay, transgender worker prote... by erichocean on Monday June 15, 2020 @02:35PM (#23531191)
Political labels are almost meaningless; always judge politics by actions, not words. The Democrat Party today is as far from Andrew Jackson (it's first President) than North Korea (the Democratic People's Republic of Korea) is from being a democracy, or a republic.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court endorses gay, transgender worker prote... by redler on Monday June 15, 2020 @04:31PM (#23532608)
The term "Democrat Party" (and, more generally, "Democrat" as an adjective) is both a shibboleth signaling opposing tribal membership, and an epithet signaling contempt for the Democratic Party — the actual name of the organization. It's adult name-calling. The usage is widely understood to be an intentional discourtesy.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court endorses gay, transgender worker prote... by pdonis on Monday June 15, 2020 @02:40PM (#23531253)
You called yourself a "Democrat". Even if you want to disclaim association with the political party that calls itself that, you still have the same problem I attributed to them.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court endorses gay, transgender worker prote... by erichocean on Monday June 15, 2020 @02:48PM (#23531368)
Judges are nominated and confirmed by elected officials, which are determined by the voters. Which part of that is "undemocratic"?
Re:U.S. Supreme Court endorses gay, transgender worker prote... by pdonis on Monday June 15, 2020 @03:22PM (#23531824)
> Which part of that is "undemocratic"?

The part where judges make political decisions that are supposed to be made by voters and their elected representatives. The fact that some busybody believes that voters "can't be relied on" to enact particular policies that the busybody favors does not justify getting those policies enacted by judges instead. Judges are not supposed to enact policies. They are supposed to say what the law is, not what someone believes it ought to be.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court endorses gay, transgender worker prote... by erichocean on Monday June 15, 2020 @03:55PM (#23532194)
> Judges are not supposed to enact policies. They are supposed to say what the law is, not what someone believes it ought to be.

I think that was true at the country's founding, but is no longer true today. The entire purpose of Civil Rights legislation was to enable the courts to "enact policies", which they have done continuously since. They are literally doing what Congress asked them to do.

If you don't like Civil Rights legislation, fine. But don't blame the courts for using it as the basis to do what Congress has clearly empowered them to do.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court endorses gay, transgender worker prote... by pdonis on Monday June 15, 2020 @04:03PM (#23532312)
> The entire purpose of Civil Rights legislation was to enable the courts to "enact policies"

Congress cannot change the structure of the government by passing a law. The Constitution makes enacting policies the job of Congress (and the President, for either signing or vetoing bills passed by Congress), not the Supreme Court. If we want the Supreme Court to be able to enact policies, we would need to amend the Constitution.

As I said in another comment upthread, I think you have a highly idiosyncratic (and wrong) view of how law in the US works.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court endorses gay, transgender worker prote... by scarface74 on Monday June 15, 2020 @04:06PM (#23532343)
Would you have preferred that judges didn’t rule the way they did in the case of Brown vs Board of Education?

The “busy bodies” are the people who want to deny employment to people just because who they share a bed with.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court endorses gay, transgender worker prote... by pdonis on Monday June 15, 2020 @04:29PM (#23532579)
> Would you have preferred that judges didn’t rule the way they did in the case of Brown vs Board of Education?

As a matter of law I would have preferred that political decisions about public schools were made by legislatures, not judges, as they are supposed to be. The idea that the purpose of government is to get our favored policies in place, by hook or by crook, is going to be the death of our republic sooner or later. The government is supposed to uphold the rule of law, and the law of the land in the US, the Constitution, does not give judges the power to make political decisions.

As a matter of policy, I would have preferred that the whole public school system in the US have either not been developed at all, or developed along very different lines. The people who put the US public school system in place were quite explicit that their purpose was to indoctrinate children. I think the government has no business indoctrinating children. But that policy question is way past any hope of repair.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court endorses gay, transgender worker prote... by scarface74 on Monday June 15, 2020 @04:37PM (#23532668)
As a matter of law I would have preferred that political decisions about public schools were made by legislatures, not judges, as they are supposed to be.

I wonder if you would have had the same preference if you had had to send your kids to separate schools, drink from separate water fountains, give up your seat on a bus for someone who was the right color or be forbidden to marry the person you love because they were a different color?

Would you also be in favor of a national religion if the majority passed such a law?

A republic that legalizes discrimination deserves to die.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court endorses gay, transgender worker prote... by pdonis on Monday June 15, 2020 @05:35PM (#23533250)
> I wonder if you would have had the same preference if you had had to send your kids to separate schools, drink from separate water fountains, give up your seat on a bus for someone who was the right color or be forbidden to marry the person you love because they were a different color?

Regarding having to send kids to separate schools, I've already given my opinion on the US public school system in general. Given how messed up I think that whole system is, having to send kids to segregated schools instead of integrated ones would rank pretty low on my list of things to complain about. I'd be far more worried about how the school was trying to indoctrinate kids than what the demographics of the student body were.

I can see the obvious equal protection argument for requiring public schools not to be segregated, which of course was basically the argument the Court used when it said "separate is inherently unequal". (Similar arguments could of course be made, and were made, for the other cases you describe.) However, if we are going to talk about equal protection, I would think having equal quality of schools available to all would be the chief requirement to impose on the government if the government is going to provide public schools at all. And even if we grant that having the demographics of the student body be representative of the community is one aspect of school quality, it certainly is not the only one or even the primary one; surely what the students are actually being taught in the classroom should count, and count for more. If all the inner city integrated schools are bad and all the suburban integrated schools are good, that's not equal protection even if the demographics of the student bodies in both cases are the same.

Once we get into considerations like that, it should be obvious that we are talking about political policy decisions that have to be made legislatively, since they involve public funds, and are fraught with difficulty even then. Nobody knows how to ensure good quality schools everywhere, or even what "good quality" really amounts to or how to judge it. Having courts try to dictate policy in this area is not likely to be helpful. And in fact, the Supreme Court in Missouri v. Jenkins explicitly ruled that courts cannot dictate policy in this area; Brown vs. Board of Education only outlaws de jure segregation, not de facto inequalities in school funding and quality that impact different races differently. In other words, the only thing the Court found itself able to enforce was the thing that, judging by how our public schools have fared since Brown was decided, has by far the least impact on the actual quality of education that public school students receive.

This is what happens when courts try to make policy: you get a symbolic victory without the substance. I think most people, if they thought about it, would prefer the substance; but the only way to get that in a democracy is by doing the hard work of changing how citizens are willing to vote.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court endorses gay, transgender worker prote... by scarface74 on Monday June 15, 2020 @05:55PM (#23533496)
Given how messed up I think that whole system is, having to send kids to segregated schools instead of integrated ones would rank pretty low on my list of things to complain about. I'd be far more worried about how the school was trying to indoctrinate kids than what the demographics of the student body were.

You really don’t know much about how bad that whole “separate but equal” thing worked out in practice? I bet a years salary that your parents never told you how bad Jim Crow laws were for minorities. Nor did they have to grow up under them.

This is what happens when courts try to make policy: you get a symbolic victory without the substance. I think most people, if they thought about it, would prefer the substance; but the only way to get that in a democracy is by doing the hard work of changing how citizens are willing to vote.

It’s easy to argue theory when you aren’t personally effected. No matter how much money I made, I wouldn’t have been allowed to buy a house in the area that I now live because of racial covenants 50 years ago. I wouldn’t have been able to move into the “good neighborhoods” where I could send my son to the “good schools”.

Sorry, I’m not fond with waiting for the “democratic process” and beg racists (speaking hypothetically if the court hadn’t overturned the laws) to vote to outlaw Jim Crow laws.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court endorses gay, transgender worker prote... by pdonis on Monday June 15, 2020 @09:04PM (#23534892)
> You really don’t know much about how bad that whole “separate but equal” thing worked out in practice?

I never said "separate but equal" wasn't bad. Remember I said that I think the whole US public school system should either not have existed at all, or should have developed along very different lines.

> I’m not fond with waiting for the “democratic process”

Then you don't want to live in a democracy. Democracy means that you change the law using the democratic process, and that all the people, even the ones whose views you abhor, have a voice in that process.

If people who take your view would admit straight up that they don't want democracy and want to abolish our democratic form of government and replace it with something that better suits them, that would be one thing. But, as I pointed out upthread, the very same people call themselves "Democrats" and say democracy is wonderful and argue that everything they are doing is perfectly consistent with the form of government we are supposed to have according to our Constitution and laws. What they mean is that democracy is wonderful as long as it does what they want, and the Constitution and laws can be set aside whenever necessary in order to achieve their policy objectives. That's not democracy, and it's not the rule of law. It's just arbitrary exercise of power according to personal opinion.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court endorses gay, transgender worker prote... by scarface74 on Monday June 15, 2020 @09:23PM (#23535005)
So I should want to live in this great theoretical democracy where the will of the majority means the government can legally discriminate against me? Or as late as 2013 , there were cases where gay people were being arrested for “sodomy” because they were having sex in their own homes? (https://slate.com/human-interest/2013/08/gay-people-are-stil...) just because those are the laws passed by the “democratic process”?

I have a strange feeling you wouldn’t feel the same way if the Democratic process infringed on your liberties.

Do you agree that I shouldn’t have been able to buy a house in a certain neighborhood because the “Democratic process” allowed racial covenants? Or that my son shouldn’t have been able to go to the school that he was zone to and instead wait on people to decide that it was okay with them even though I was paying taxes too?

Re:U.S. Supreme Court endorses gay, transgender worker prote... by pdonis on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @09:16AM (#23538774)
> So I should want to live in this great theoretical democracy where the will of the majority means the government can legally discriminate against me?

What kind of society you want to live in is up to you. Just don't pretend that you want to live in the kind of society that our Constitution and laws describe, if you actually don't.

> I have a strange feeling you wouldn’t feel the same way if the Democratic process infringed on your liberties.

According to our Constitution and laws, it can't. The fact that it often does is a sign that our so-called "Democratic process" is actually not respecting our Constitution and laws, but is instead based on arbitrary exercises of power. Adding more arbitrary exercises of power to the mix does not help fix that problem.

> Do you agree that I shouldn’t have been able to buy a house in a certain neighborhood because the “Democratic process” allowed racial covenants?

Do you think such covenants are allowed by the Constitution and the Bill of Rights?

> Or that my son shouldn’t have been able to go to the school that he was zone to and instead wait on people to decide that it was okay with them even though I was paying taxes too?

Do you think that policy is consistent with the Constitution and the Bill of Rights?

Re:U.S. Supreme Court endorses gay, transgender worker prote... by scarface74 on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @02:15PM (#23542265)
Well, in both cases the “democratic elected representatives” thought so until “activist judges” got involved.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court endorses gay, transgender worker prote... by pdonis on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @03:40PM (#23543196)
I didn't ask what they thought. I asked what you think.

If your answer is that you just accept whatever the "activist judges" think as a corrective to what the "democratically elected representatives" think, then you are just as much at the mercy of what the "activist judges" believe as a black person in the Jim Crow South was at the mercy of what the "democratically elected representatives" believed. The "activist judges" did something you agree with this time, but they could just as well do something you disagree with, or that prevents you from doing something you want to do or takes away something you think you have a right to, next time.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court endorses gay, transgender worker prote... by scarface74 on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @04:32PM (#23543703)
I trust “activist judges” who aren’t subject to the whims and votes of “religious people” who believe that a book written over two millennium ago means that if they allow homosexual acts and “race mixing” that they will damn the country to hell.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court endorses gay, transgender worker prote... by scarface74 on Monday June 15, 2020 @04:05PM (#23532332)
Maybe it’s because the majority should never have the right to impinge on basic liberties because of religious beliefs — see also, laws against “sodomy” (non heterosexual sex) and laws against “miscegenation” (interracial marriage).
Re:U.S. Supreme Court endorses gay, transgender worker prote... by rayiner on Monday June 15, 2020 @09:54PM (#23535182)
What’s a “basic liberty?” Who gets to decide? What happens if the majority literally believes that God will punish their society if it condones “sinful” behavior? You can say that religious beliefs shouldn’t be the basis of law, but who put you in charge? And what happens when people’s “basic liberties” conflict? Isn’t freedom of association a “basic liberty?” Is there somewhere in the constitution that says it doesn’t apply to employers?

I view the legal process like arguing with your spouse. Every win has a cost. Every victory for individual self determination achieved through litigation chips away at the right of collective self determination, and that’s not cost free.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court endorses gay, transgender worker prote... by scarface74 on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @09:18AM (#23538789)
So we can argue theory all day long. Do you think a “democracy” should have the right to imprison someone who marries someone of a different race or if two consenting adults decide to have sex?

In this case at hand. Do you think someone should end up dying because they can’t get healthcare because of prejudice against the trans community?

Re:U.S. Supreme Court endorses gay, transgender worker prote... by rayiner on Monday June 15, 2020 @03:38PM (#23531999)
> I think you answer your own objection right there. Conservatives don't conserve anything, it's liberalism with a speed limit. The United States doesn't have any party that is interested in conserving anything cultural or legal, anywhere. Which is great for Democrats (like myself).

It’s a rare moment when people can agree on what’s happening while disagreeing on whether it’s good or bad. This is exactly the criticism conservatives have about the Court.

We have had a “conservative” majority Supreme Court for almost 50 years, and on social issues we have gone at more or less the same pace as Western Europe. (I would like to think that conservatives had a hand in filtering out a bunch of dead ends they liberals otherwise would have led us down.) For example, same-sex marriage:

> In 2001, the Netherlands[b] became the first country to establish same-sex marriage by law.[124] Since then same-sex marriage has also been established by law in Belgium (2003), Spain (2005), Canada (2005), South Africa (2006), Norway (2009), Sweden (2009), Portugal (2010), Iceland (2010), Argentina (2010), Denmark (2012), Brazil (2013), France (2013), Uruguay (2013), New Zealand[c] (2013), Luxembourg (2015), the United States[e] (2015), Ireland (2015), Colombia (2016), Finland (2017), Malta (2017), Germany (2017), Australia (2017), Austria (2019), Taiwan (2019), Ecuador (2019), the United Kingdom[d] (2020), and Costa Rica (2020). In Mexico, same-sex marriage is performed in several states and recognized in all thirty-one states.