News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft sues Barnes & Noble over Android in Nook by tzs on Monday March 21, 2011 @10:25PM (#2352718)
I'm going to make this a stand-alone comment instead of inserting it to an existing comment thread, because there are too many places it could be reasonably inserted.

If you do not read the description of a patent, and then read the claims, interpreting them in light of the description, you have NO CLUE what the patent covers. If you do read the description and claims, then you MIGHT have a good idea of what the patent covers. To fully understand it, you have to get a copy of the file wrapper, which contains the correspondence between the Patent Office and the applicant.

The file wrapper is important because if the applicant argues for a narrow interpretation of something in the patent in order to get the examiner to approve, that narrow interpretation is what will apply when the patentee tries to enforce the patent.

For those who want to read the patents, I recommend using pat2pdf.org to get them. You can give that site a patent number and it will give you a nice PDF of the patent. The links most people are citing (including the submitted article) are to the USPTO, which is not as nice. In particular the images are not available on some OS/browser combinations. A PDF from pat2pdf.org works everywhere.

I don't know if there is a way to get the file wrapper for free, but you can get the history for free from the patent office. To illustrate how important the file wrapper can be, of the patents in question:

5,778,372: it was initially rejected (a non-final rejection, which I believe means the examiner is open to hear more arguments).

6,339,780: it was rejected five times (3 non-final, 2 final which I believe means Microsoft had to convince someone to override the examiner but hopefully a patent attorney or agent will jump in and clarify).

5,889,522: rejected three times (2 non-final, 1 final).

6,891,551: two rejections (1 non-final, 1 final).

6,957,233: two rejections (1 non-final, 1 final).

PS: it looks like you can perhaps get the documents in the file wrapper free online here: http://portal.uspto.gov/external/portal/pair

There are no comments on this comment yet.