Re:Ask HN: How do you feel about affirmative action and reve...
by Animus7 on Monday March 21, 2011 @10:20PM
(#2352700)
In capitalism the only way to go is to hire based on merit. You have to ignore the issue of privelage; that's a separate social problem.
Otherwise, things stop making sense: should we be forced by law to hire unqualified employees just because there's uneducated people that want jobs?
I'm a Canadian living in the US and I find it fascinating that a lot of people (esp. in software) are so very concerned that hiring be based on merit. That perspective completely leaves out an analysis that merit is something you can often only build on top of privilege. There's a great cartoon that I cannot find but which sums it up nicely. A white boy and a black boy come upon a high ledge and want to explore what's up there. So the white boy gets the black boy to give him a boost and climbs on top of him to reach the ledge. Then when the black boy reaches his hand up to ask for a lift getting up there himself the white boy says "You have to get up here on your own, I did".
It's too easy to say we make decisions "blind" or based on "merit" and that therefore removes the need for a deeper analysis of race, class and gender in our society. When we make decisions blind we might assume the pool being drawn from is fair to begin with and that those with merit naturally bubble up to the top but to really have a fair why not actually invite, engage, and draw in more people with a wider diversity so that you then know you will choose on real merit and not merit in a silo of white (and often male) privilege?