Re:Microsoft sues Barnes & Noble over Android in Nook
by muhfuhkuh on Monday March 21, 2011 @06:47PM
(#2352010)
I'm quite sure that somehow, there was a web server or email system that has transferred, stored, and otherwise "managed" a PDF with graphics in it in 1995 or before. How on earth is that not prior art?
Re:Microsoft sues Barnes & Noble over Android in Nook
by kenjackson on Monday March 21, 2011 @06:52PM
(#2352031)
What does managing a PDF with graphics have to do with it? Is there something inherent in PDF files that capture this behavior?
Re:Microsoft sues Barnes & Noble over Android in Nook
by bmelton on Monday March 21, 2011 @07:56PM
(#2352237)
I'm pretty sure a PDF is served as a single file. The 'parts' of a PDF aren't loaded seperately, and hence aren't streamed individually of the entire document.
Re:Microsoft sues Barnes & Noble over Android in Nook
by rbanffy on Monday March 21, 2011 @06:46PM
(#2352008)
I am quite sure pre-98 Netscape did that.
Re:Microsoft sues Barnes & Noble over Android in Nook
by kenjackson on Monday March 21, 2011 @06:47PM
(#2352012)
The filing was April '96, so it would have to be before that. Netscape may have. In which case, this will be easy to invalidate. If Netscape didn't, I think it will be a lot tougher as the current bar for invalidating patents in court is pretty high.
AFAIK, PDF doesn't specify these things. And to be clear the patent isn't about a file format. It's about the method one uses to retrieve and display the document.