Re:How to Build a Universe That Doesn't Fall Apart Two Days ...
by perl4ever on Saturday June 13, 2020 @11:56AM
(#23510315)
It's not just that they were conquered, but then they were defined as uniquely evil for all time, but then the struggle to maintain that and include or exclude others as similar never ends. Godwin's law wouldn't be a thing if anyone controlled language even in this specific area. People wouldn't to this day casually compare people and groups to Nazis if there was such a thing as controlling people through language.
Given your statement that "enhanced interrogation" is still going on, that means from my framing that calling it torture failed to stop it, hence attempts to control it through language failed. You're saying that language allows it to happen, but I would say the correct framing is that doing it and the desire of people to rationalize it allows it to happen. The euphemism being an effect rather than a cause.
Re:How to Build a Universe That Doesn't Fall Apart Two Days ...
by watwut on Sunday June 14, 2020 @02:05AM
(#23515478)
That sounds illogical to me. You define "controlling through something" in a way that makes it impossible.
Yes, nazi lost wwii, no it does not prove their control of langue failed.
No, there being two opposing sides trying to control langue and one of them not winning does not prove control through langue does not work.
Frankly, there are very illogical argument.
And in nazi example, successful controll of how Jews are seen does not imply that foreign non-Jewish armies will never beat you. That would be ridiculous standard.
Nazi succesfull framed Jews as evil and Jews got exterminated. They succesfully framed slavs as inferior and succesfully framed themselves as needing more living space which led to expansive war and population displacement.
That foreign armies conguered them does not imply that messaging aimed at Germans was not succesfull.