Re:Ask HN: My wife might lose the ability to speak in 3 week...
by gnulinux on Friday June 12, 2020 @09:26AM
(#23498981)
If you learned French or Chinese the same way you learned ASL you could have made the same argument for these languages. My comment wasn't a point about how ASL is taught or the pedagogy of ASL learning -- these are things I know nothing about. I was just explaining the linguistic properties of ASL. But you're right, in retrospect I should not have used the analogy with Chinese, it really isn't a good analogy since learning a spoken language is a different experience than learning a sign language. I was just trying to point out the "linguistic distance" between English and ASL.
Re:Ask HN: My wife might lose the ability to speak in 3 week...
by thaumasiotes on Thursday June 11, 2020 @09:01PM
(#23494911)
> In my experience, learning ASL is more akin to riding a bike, than learning a romance language -- much less Chinese.
The fact that you had formal language classes in romance languages doesn't mean that's the only way romance languages can be taught or learned. You can learn or teach any language however you want. Some ways are more effective; some are less effective.
One reason students can't speak any French after taking four years of school French is that effectiveness isn't really a goal of the instruction (or of the students).
The romance languages were taught in English, with a strong focus on the rules. Progress was extremely slow. I've had opportunities to practice Spanish and Italian, and that's been way more helpful than those classes ever were (and let's be honest, Spanish and Italian are too similar for my muddled brain and "communication" is more of a negotiation). I've heard from quite a few students of French that after 4 years of formal study, they can't speak a lick. I didn't hang on that long.
ASL is often taught immersively. You might have an interpreter for the first day or the first week, but after that, it's voices off (and if you're lucky, your instructor is Deaf). You start with letters, to bootstrap from English, and mimeing, because that forms a basis for a lot of informal ASL. Subsequent vocabulary is communicated through a combination of fingerspelling and mime. Grammar is considered a fairly advanced topic; and by the time your teacher gets around to that, you'll have absorbed more of it than you realize.
In my experience, learning ASL is more akin to riding a bike, than learning a romance language -- much less Chinese.