Re:Racist Magic: The Gathering cards banned, removed from da...
by duskwuff on Thursday June 11, 2020 @07:31PM
(#23494320)
The name and art for Pradesh Gypsies wasn't the problem. The card text was the issue -- it had an ability which could temporarily reduce the strength of an opponent's card, invoking the stereotype of a thieving gypsy.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Racist Magic: The Gathering cards banned, removed from da...
by toyg on Thursday June 11, 2020 @07:39PM
(#23494370)
Applying a negative modifier to opponents is “invoking stereotypes of thieving”...?
That modifier might as well come from outwitting or befuddling, particularly with a text that evokes mystery.
Sounds to me like this choice says more about the actual prejudices of whoever made it, rather than objective parameters.
Re:Racist Magic: The Gathering cards banned, removed from da...
by kthejoker2 on Friday June 12, 2020 @08:47AM
(#23498661)
The issue is using "Gypsies", period, when there's no need to do so.
If you replaced it with "Wanderers" nothing of value is lost.
Using a real group name is thr only reason your comment (and this one) exists.
It literally creates tension where none should be by its very existence. That's problematic.
Re:Racist Magic: The Gathering cards banned, removed from da...
by lsiebert on Thursday June 11, 2020 @07:44PM
(#23494409)
The name IS problematic.
Re:Racist Magic: The Gathering cards banned, removed from da...
by duskwuff on Thursday June 11, 2020 @08:32PM
(#23494727)
You're right, that's a fair point. I wouldn't be surprised if WotC had avoided "Romani" because it felt like a demonym which wouldn't exist in their universe. :/
Are there any great substitute terms which focus on the lifestyle commonly associated with the Romani? "Nomadic" (or "nomads") is associated more with peoples who live away from civilization; "travelers" is a little weak, as it can imply a temporary activity.