Re:Ask HN: What are we doing wrong now that will be painfull...
by TomMarius on Thursday June 11, 2020 @01:09PM
(#23490949)
The problem isn't that they were held (ISIS didn't have resources for such large scale operation), but that no place has accepted them.
Re:Ask HN: What are we doing wrong now that will be painfull...
by dragonwriter on Thursday June 11, 2020 @01:17PM
(#23491024)
“No place accepted them” is also largely denial by force (both at boundaries and in the interior of they manage to evade it at boundaries), just from the other direction.
I'd say it is almost the reverse; the desire to establish a captive population is what leads one to seek power through violence.
> If people have freedom of movement, it's much harder to subjugate them by holding land.
If you hold land by force, you can thereby deny people freedom of movement in any direction. That's actually the only way to deny people freedom of movement, whether you concentrate on the inbound direction (as many countries do whether or not they also care about the other direction) or the outbound direction (Cold War East Germany, for a well-known example).