Re:Who builds a house without drawing blueprints? (2015)
by imtringued on Thursday June 11, 2020 @08:21AM
(#23488027)
The building analogy doesn't work because the situation is completely reversed. Building commercial software is much cheaper than designing it. Constructing a building is much more expensive than designing it.
Specifications are expensive and since designing software is risky the specification forces you to take the entire risk upfront. Lots of projects stop after a failed MVP to cut losses. You can't do that with a well thought out specification.
There are obviously well studied areas of computer science where the opposite is true. Compilers, databases and simulations benefit from a good design but this is precisely because of their well studied nature. The only way to get an edge in the commercial world is by doing something nobody else did before. That often means nobody, including the creator of the software, knows what the best design is.
This commonly results in an "idiotic market leader" effect where a product with obvious flaws (say mongodb) somehow manages to dominate a market.
Specifications are expensive and since designing software is risky the specification forces you to take the entire risk upfront. Lots of projects stop after a failed MVP to cut losses. You can't do that with a well thought out specification.
There are obviously well studied areas of computer science where the opposite is true. Compilers, databases and simulations benefit from a good design but this is precisely because of their well studied nature. The only way to get an edge in the commercial world is by doing something nobody else did before. That often means nobody, including the creator of the software, knows what the best design is.
This commonly results in an "idiotic market leader" effect where a product with obvious flaws (say mongodb) somehow manages to dominate a market.