Re:HTTPS is more secure, so why isn't the Web using it?
by tedunangst on Monday March 21, 2011 @01:16AM
(#2348579)
It provides protection if you have access to a reasonably trusted network. Let's say HN adds https with a self signed cert. I trust my home network, more or less, so I'll agree and accept the cert. Then if I take my laptop on the road, I can verify that the cert I'm getting over public wifi is the same cert I downloaded at home. That is tons better than the current "broadcast your password in plaintext" scenario we've got going on now.
It means you can't trust sites if you're out of the house and you haven't been there before, but every site I care about trusting gets visited from in my house.
And how big are certs? Not that big. It's conceivable you could download a bundle of them beforehand. We're getting almost back to CA land, though, so I'm going to cut this idea short, but you can imagine a service that collects certs and verifies nothing except that they are the same as they were last week.
It means you can't trust sites if you're out of the house and you haven't been there before, but every site I care about trusting gets visited from in my house.
And how big are certs? Not that big. It's conceivable you could download a bundle of them beforehand. We're getting almost back to CA land, though, so I'm going to cut this idea short, but you can imagine a service that collects certs and verifies nothing except that they are the same as they were last week.