News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:BHP to destroy at least 40 Aboriginal sites, up to 15K ye... by redslazer on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @11:20PM (#23484904)
While the destruction of these sites is most probably not a good idea and there is an open question regarding the fairness of native title negotiations between mining companies and the local indigenous people it should be noted that:

"They are also unable to raise concerns publicly about the expansion, having signed comprehensive agreements with BHP as part of a native title settlement. BHP agreed to financial and other benefits for the Banjima people, while the Banjima made commitments to support the South Flank project."

From the sounds of it the two parties have agreed to the situation and now one party is attempting to escape its part of the agreement through the use public opinion.

Re:BHP to destroy at least 40 Aboriginal sites, up to 15K ye... by yongjik on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @11:35PM (#23484975)
If some house in Greece is sitting on the ruins of the classical era, and its owner sells the house to some mining company, can't people protest the impending destruction?

It doesn't seem right to treat 15K-year-old archeological sites as sellable goods. It should belong to Australia and mankind.

Re:BHP to destroy at least 40 Aboriginal sites, up to 15K ye... by dependenttypes on Thursday June 11, 2020 @12:59AM (#23485343)
I think that in some countries at least the moment that an archeological site is discovered it becomes property of the government.
Re:BHP to destroy at least 40 Aboriginal sites, up to 15K ye... by noobermin on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @11:29PM (#23484954)
That's good. Onerous one sided agreements are terrible especially when one part has so much power over the other.
[dead]
Re:BHP to destroy at least 40 Aboriginal sites, up to 15K ye... by NoPicklez on Thursday June 11, 2020 @01:11AM (#23485391)
But they are historical due to the aboriginal inhabitants of that land at that time.

How are the owners of that land who are aboriginal not have a right to allow the removal of such places if agreed?

Re:BHP to destroy at least 40 Aboriginal sites, up to 15K ye... by waheoo on Thursday June 11, 2020 @01:41AM (#23485528)
Same way if you own a terrace house in downtown Sydney youre only allowed to do certain things to maintain the historic nature of the buildings.

Same way we say you cant dump chemical waste on land you own just because you own it.

We place restrictions on usage rights all the damn time.

Re:BHP to destroy at least 40 Aboriginal sites, up to 15K ye... by BubRoss on Thursday June 11, 2020 @12:51AM (#23485311)
Were you upset about this before the article?
[dead]
Re:BHP to destroy at least 40 Aboriginal sites, up to 15K ye... by happytoexplain on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @11:36PM (#23484986)
Why insult the parent so sarcastically? Why tell somebody their opinion doesn't matter, ever?