News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:From chaos to free will by vidarh on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @12:02PM (#23478615)
For me it is the idea of what it would mean to actually have free will that makes my mind hurts, because it is such an bizarre idea. Maybe it is because of decades of software development hammering in causality.

Because free will implies that cause and effect breaks down, but in a way that is not random but governed by some agency that is not following the cause and effect of the physical structure of the brain.

Where would that agency come from? How would it enable a decision that is not then just deterministic one step removed, or randomness one step removed, or agency one step removed?

And so we have infinite regression: For each additional step of agency you add to sidestep the problem, the same questions arises of how the decision can be made without being a combination of determinism and randomness or involve some external agency...

Conversely, the idea that we do not have free will is easy to resolve for me: Consider yourself a character in a movie. Conceptually your character has free will within the movie universe. Your character could have chosen differently if it had been written differently. But in the movie they will always make the same choice, no matter how many times you rewind, because the choice is already locked in.

Re:From chaos to free will by apta on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @02:32PM (#23480471)
If there's no free will as you're positing, what logically follows is that we should not have a legal system. Why punish someone because they stole for example? It was all pre-determined. This is where this line of reasoning breaks apart quickly. Just because our minds can't rationalize the vast unknowns of the universe, doesn't mean that we should jump to simplistic conclusions based on our experiences.
Re:From chaos to free will by vidarh on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @03:00PM (#23480756)
No, it follows that we should model the legal system on the basis of what protects society with the least damage to the people we lock up, on the basis that they had no choice. We still have a reason to protect others.

And arguing that it 'breaks' apart because you don't like the consequences is ludicrous.

Give me a definition of free will that doesn't suffer the problems I described, and we can talk.

Re:From chaos to free will by apta on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @06:48PM (#23483089)
You seem to be arguing from an agnostic or atheist point of view (correct me if I'm wrong). If that's the case, then there is no incentive whatsoever to limit the "damage" to the people who do get locked up, because it's meaningless. Whether they get locked up for 1 year, 10, or just straight out executed, it's all the same. Rape isn't inherently bad anymore, it just is. Same with murder, theft, etc.
Re:From chaos to free will by slfnflctd on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @10:48PM (#23484762)
I think you understand where I'm coming from.

I'm not authoritarian by any means, and I think defunding a bunch of police departments in the U.S. might be a good idea, but when people start acting like everything is deterministic society falls apart. You have different outcomes than you would otherwise have. I know this from having given up on life a few times.

Re:From chaos to free will by vidarh on Thursday June 11, 2020 @04:29AM (#23486462)
A religious view makes no difference - it just pushes the question back one step.

And yes there is every incentive to limit damage, to protect people even if there was no decision. But that also then extends to the perpetrators.

There is no logic at all to your assertions here.

Re:From chaos to free will by apta on Thursday June 11, 2020 @11:16AM (#23489750)
> A religious view makes no difference - it just pushes the question back one step.

I disagree. You have well-known atheist figures that have expressed views similar to what I was describing. That rape isn't inherently bad, it's just something that exists in the world. That incest is ok if it's between "consenting adults". Or Dawkins defending pedophilia. There literally isn't a gauge to determine whether something is moral or not anymore. It may sound absurd or over-exaggerating, but that is the logical conclusion of a purely materialistic view. We've seen its effects throughout history.

Re:From chaos to free will by mslm on Thursday June 11, 2020 @05:18AM (#23486770)
> No, it follows that we should model the legal system on the basis of what protects society with the least damage to the people we lock up, on the basis that they had no choice.

How does this follow "logically"? This is just an opinion.

In the end of the day if _everyone_ had no free will, legal systems are besides the question - we would busy ourselves in figuring out whether someone is going to commit a crime before it is committed, and would be capable of doing so highly reliably with enough technological advancement. Some war criminals today think they can already do that, killing innocent children by familial association to terrorists.

Re:From chaos to free will by vidarh on Thursday June 11, 2020 @09:49AM (#23488826)
> How does this follow "logically"? This is just an opinion.

On the basis that there is no justification for "punishment" or "vengeance" based on responsibility if there was no choice. We still need a legal system because events still happen that causes harm and that needs to be resolved, but if we acknowledge people have no agency, then there is no justification for assigning blame, but still a need to e.g. prevent reoccurrence. But when we take steps to protect society against people we recognize are blameless or without agency today, such as e.g. mentally ill people or children, we aim to pick the least invasive means possible, because we recognize it is not meant to be a punishment.

> In the end of the day if _everyone_ had no free will, legal systems are besides the question - we would busy ourselves in figuring out whether someone is going to commit a crime before it is committed, and would be capable of doing so highly reliably with enough technological advancement. Some war criminals today think they can already do that, killing innocent children by familial association to terrorists.

No, this does not follow for two reasons: 1) Sheer systems complexity. E.g. we still can't reliably predict the weather, and the weather is far simpler to predict because of 2: 2) it devolves trivially to the halting problem, in that actions can and would change depending on our actions to try to prevent crime, because people, deterministic or not, act on input from the environment in extremely complex manners.

As such it is wildly unreasonable to think that we can remove crime. Reduce it, sure. We know many ways of doing that: Redistribution for example; poverty is a massive driver of crime. Education; low education is a massive driver of crime. And so on. But nothing we do will remove the need for a legal system at any point in the near future.

Your war criminal example is an example of #2 above: how response feeds back into actions, and part of why trying to resolve this issue will remain largely as difficult.

But it would be easier, as harsh punishment-focused legal systems are a massive driver of high reoffending rates.

Re:From chaos to free will by dragonwriter on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @02:36PM (#23480512)
> If there's no free will as you're positing, what logically follows is that we should not have a legal system.

That does not follow. In fact, the idea that we “should” or “should not” is irrelevant unless you assume free will. Because what we should do only matters if we have a choice.

Re:From chaos to free will by apta on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @06:50PM (#23483111)
So as you're putting it, it doesn't matter, it's all the same either way whether we or don't have a legal system. So why punish people if they don't have free will?
Re:From chaos to free will by dragonwriter on Thursday June 11, 2020 @09:04AM (#23488367)
> So as you're putting it, it doesn't matter, it's all the same either way whether we or don't have a legal system.

No, I'm saying if we don't have free will, having a legal system or not isn't a choice either. If the actions a legal system might regulate are predetermined, so is whether or not we have a legal system, and what the nature of that system is.

> So why punish people if they don't have free will?

If we don't have free will, what does the question “Why?” even mean, other than asking for an explanation of the mechanical forces producing an outcome? Questions of purpose behind actions presuppose free will directing actions for a purpose.

Re:From chaos to free will by vidarh on Thursday June 11, 2020 @04:32AM (#23486478)
You would have an interest in doing what minimises harm to society rather than for punishment. That means focusing on rehabilitation rather than vengeance.

Consider that eg the US legal system has absolutely awful reoffending rates compared to eg Norway - it is geared for punishment rather than minimising harm.

Re:From chaos to free will by adjkant on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @01:45PM (#23479912)
And that doesn't get into the weeds even! If we follow that computer model style of thinking, I think it's quite interesting that we still have no real randomness in computing, only computing seemingly random signals from the outside world.