News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:From chaos to free will by analog31 on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @11:31PM (#23473622)
In my view, that's a straw man. I don't think physicists believe that. I think that most physicists are comfortable treating some phenomena such as nuclear decay and shot noise as truly random. Whether that's a useful model or a fundamental truth is actually something that's not of practical interest outside of perhaps a very small cadre of theoreticians.

But one of my physics professors had an amusing comment: We can't calculate the energy levels of the hydrogen atom in years of CPU time, but the hydrogen atom can compute its own wavefunction in a femtosecond. Aside from microscopic phenomena, at least macroscopic systems can compute their own future just fine.

My own view is that free will is a theological / philosophical solution in search of a scientific problem.

Re:From chaos to free will by jbay808 on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @11:50PM (#23473716)
I agree that nuclear decay is random, but I wouldn't say it's necessarily an example of non-determinism in the universe. As a subscriber to multiverse theory, I'd say that the appearance of random outcomes is just the way it feels to be a human in a quantum superposition.