Re:Playing around with the Fuchsia operating system
by VWWHFSfQ on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @01:24PM
(#23468656)
> Minix 3 is a true microkernel, and is currently a popular niche OS
Isn't it the most widely deployed operating system in the world? It's embedded in basically every Intel CPU
Re:Playing around with the Fuchsia operating system
by teho on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @01:43PM
(#23468864)
This keeps getting repeated, but I don’t understand how that would lead to it being the most popular OS there is. There is way more embedded systems than there is Intel CPUs on the market and they often run Linux. Android phones are sold more than four times the amount of PCs a year. I’d assume that most Intel CPUs are deployed in the data centers... that run Linux.
Re:Playing around with the Fuchsia operating system
by VWWHFSfQ on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @01:56PM
(#23469001)
but the cpus deployed in datacenters also run minix. even the ones running linux. or windows
Re:Playing around with the Fuchsia operating system
by teho on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @03:20PM
(#23469837)
Yeah, but the point was that there is without a doubt more Linux instances running on ARM than there is Intel CPUs in total. Then even from the Intel processors that do have Minix, a sizable amount is running Linux. Therefore Minix can’t be nearly as widely used as Linux.
Re:Playing around with the Fuchsia operating system
by ardacinar on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @02:17PM
(#23469166)
What about the ones that are on fridges?
Re:Playing around with the Fuchsia operating system
by atombender on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @01:55PM
(#23468988)
But they said "widely deployed", not "popular". No one is claiming Minix is the most popular OS in the world.
Re:Playing around with the Fuchsia operating system
by zucker42 on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @01:46PM
(#23468892)
There are far more phones than desktops, and far more desktops than servers, so I doubt it. Especially if you count by OS instance (counting VMs) rather than by machine.
Re:Playing around with the Fuchsia operating system
by atombender on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @01:36PM
(#23468798)
True!
However, core components such as graphics, file systems, hardware devices, etc. are moved into userland, so in that sense it follows the microkernel idea of putting as little as possible in the kernel itself.
Personally, I love the design, and hope it takes off. We really need to get away from letting kernels and devices have elevated privileges in an OS.
As far as I'm concerned, Tanenbaum won the monolith/microkernel debate — Minix 3 is a true microkernel, and is currently a popular niche OS — and the success of Linux does not diminish the argument. (The infamous failure of GNU Hurd doesn't, either.)