That seems more like a baseline case than the worse one. I feel like I could definitely come up with one that’s worse than random. Negative points for indications of intelligence, knowledge, collaboration, and kindness.
Not everything has to be measurable to make good decisions.
It is a method and it may even lead to great hires but it also throws fairness out the door.
You trust your gut when you have no other option, not because you believe it to be better than a data driven approach
Do you measure your romantic relationships or marriage or family interactions? Do you measure any human relationship?Because hiring and working with someone with fundamentally a relationship, not a data science or math problem.
I had a manager once who said, "if it can't be measured, it can't be managed." You sound like him. Good luck with that approach, and i hope we don't work together :)
I disagree with the filtering attitude. Everybody wants the best candidate but they are not offering the best job.
If you can, hire the first person who convinced you that it's not going to be tough to work with and build an adult and professional relationship where each side is clear on expectations and demands.
Of course if you need a specialist, then be clear (and feel free to check) that specific ability are required. But why don't you have the time to make somebody grow organically those ability/knowledge internally?
The worst filter is choosing at random. If I shuffle a stack of resumes and throw half in the trash, I have eliminated the unlucky candidates. I have certainly rejected a good number of skilled and highly qualified candidates. Regardless the filter did its job, I have fewer applications to review.
If I give candidates whiteboard problems, I filtered out thoughtful people who don’t perform well under pressure. If I look at interviewees github submission and blog posts I have filtered out intelligent people with a dearth of free time. If I combine the two filters with an OR relationship, I now let more people through and have a filter that is less effective at narrowing down candidates.
All filters filter out good candidates. Anyone who finds a way to find exactly the right candidates from a filter in a way that isn’t bespoke and is scalable is going to be very successful.