As you said yourself, it was a good design to win the prize. That to me is the key. It did everything it set out to accomplish. Your comments all relate to the scaled up SpaceShipTwo - a completely different vehicle - which I agree that the jury might still be out on. But to me, that’s like saying that a hang glider is a bad idea if someone tries to make a hang glider for ten people. Is it the hang glider that’s the bad idea or the fact that someone’s trying to scale something that maybe doesn’t scale well?
That it was the first private crewed spaceflight shouldn’t be underestimated either. I think this list of human spaceflights really puts it in context: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_human_spaceflights
Thanks for reading and for your perspective.
The killer feature of the shuttle was supposed to be the cost savings from being able to make multiple trips using the same equipment (sound familiar?). It turned out not to be a feasible solution from a technical cost standpoint, but if people can't clearly estimate the cost of adding a new feature to a website, I totally believe would have been indistinguishable from a good idea at the time.
The shuttle turned out not to be a feasible solution because it was loaded down with other requirements that had nothing to do with the killer feature you describe. A key one was the requirement from the US Air Force that the shuttle have enough cross range capability to be launched into a polar orbit and then return to the launch site after one orbit [1]. That was what drove costs up to the point where the shuttle wasn't feasible any more in terms of the killer feature.
To be precise, it was a good design to satisfy the artificial requirements of the prize, but nothing else. The design doesn't scale. The hybrid rocket motor has been the source of countless headaches, lousy performance, and more than a decade of delays, the feathering mechanism has already cost the life of a test pilot, and the need for a pilot plus co-pilot severely reduces the payload capacity.
Now, the article's thesis – that good and bad ideas are sometimes hard to distinguish before they've been tried – is still true, but the author chose a bad example.