There was nothing fundamentally wrong with LTCM's business model, or with writing puts. Where they failed was in their execution - they underestimated the risk of fat-tails, and the level of correlation between different securities.
There are lots of cases where we do things that could potentially be catastrophic, but we do them anyway because the risk-reward justifies it. For example, going on a road trip instead of sitting at home and watching TV. The upside of going on a road trip is bounded (fun holiday) but the downside is catastrophic (deadly car crash). If we avoided every single activity that involved catastrophic risk, our lives would be far worse.
The 2008 mortgage crisis didn't have unlimited downside, but an awful lot of parties were making tiny slivers of money off things they thought had zero chance of default whose default risk was both higher and correlated.
Nuclear power arguably goes in this category too: it's mostly great, which is why people quoting numbers of deaths claim it's safe, apart from the couple of catastrophes that have left huge areas of contaminated land.
If you're trying something that has no risk to others and the worst case for you is the loss of your investment, feel free to go for it. If the worst case affects others negatively or your liability might be more than your investment, you should definitely think twice.
Oh, and be very careful about margin investing and options trading for non-specialists.