News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Largest Known Maya Structure Found by nkoren on Monday June 08, 2020 @06:34AM (#23455357)
Hey, I'm neither a Catholic nor a monotheist. I've got no personal dog in this fight, except that as a rule, my sympathies are generally aligned with indigenous peoples. And yeah, people can be super hypocritical: mote in your eye vs. the beam in my own, et cetera. And yeah, I agree that the genocidal excess commited by the conquistadores was, taken as a whole, the worst thing happening in the Americas at the time.

But Diego de Landa wasn't taking it in as a whole. He was just having his personal experience. There's little reason to doubt the child sacrifice incident: that kind of thing absolutely did occur, and is well-attested both textually and archeologically. He didn't have the 10,000' view of the American genocide: he had a personal view, and he acted accordingly.

Usually I'm not this sympathetic. When I read first-hand accounts of Pizzaro's conquest of the Inca at Cajamarca, for example, I'm appalled. Pizzaro's guys take umbrage at the Incan' Emporer disrespecting a bible by throwing it, incomprehending, on the ground. In retribution for this, they delight -- positively delight -- in immediately slaughtering several thousand unarmed members of the emperor's court. It's absolutely sick and indefensible, driven by a religious zealotry that (IMHO) had stripped them of their basic humanity.

I'd always assumed that Diego de Landa was a similar kind of zealot, but when I read more, I found that it wasn't so simple. That's all I'm saying. Even when things are black and white at a high level, there can be greys in the details.

Re:Largest Known Maya Structure Found by hliyan on Monday June 08, 2020 @08:35AM (#23455941)
I read your original comment as a simple historical statement that did it's best to make it clear that it was speculation about a possible cause and not a justification. Not sure why the GP is reading a moral stance into it.
[dead]
Re:Largest Known Maya Structure Found by hliyan on Monday June 08, 2020 @08:37AM (#23455958)
> There is no justification for this inquisition

I believe you may be confusing cause with justification.

Re:Largest Known Maya Structure Found by dntbnmpls on Monday June 08, 2020 @07:50PM (#23462099)
No. I'm not confusing anything.

"...this is probably not politically correct to say, but I did develop some sympathy for that bishop."

Sympathy implies justification. Also, I clearly explained what caused the bishop's inquisition.

Lets switch it up. Imagine after reading mein kampf or a biography on hitler, nkoren wrote the following.

"...this is probably not politically correct to say, but I did develop some sympathy for that fuhrer."

I bet I wouldn't have gotten flagged and mass downvoted. nkoren's pathetic post is just carefully repackaged white supremacy/white man's burden. I'm surprised nkoren didn't come back with "it was cultural genocide not real genocide". There are a handful oft-repeated racist genocide denial.